11951 Homes for Sale in Fire Island, NY & Real Estate

Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$329,000
$264
/ ft²
For Sale
4
Bed
1
Bath
1,244
ft²
$264
/ ft²
House, Updated 18 hours ago
$497 / mo
Expenses
11.5%
Cap Rate
Listed Jun 25th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$305,774
For Sale
3
Bed
1.5
Bath
House, Updated 18 hours ago
$772 / mo
Expenses
7.56%
Cap Rate
Amenities Updated
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$219,000
$209
/ ft²
For Sale
3
Bed
1
Bath
1,050
ft²
$209
/ ft²
House, Listed Jul 12th, 2020
$450 / mo
Expenses
12.33%
Cap Rate
Listed Jul 12th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$399,000
For Sale
Multifamily, Listed Jul 12th, 2020
$867 / mo
Expenses
5.65%
Cap Rate
Listed Jul 12th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$209,000
$268
/ ft²
For Sale
3
Bed
1
Bath
780
ft²
$268
/ ft²
House, Updated 2 days ago
$271 / mo
Expenses
14.52%
Cap Rate
Price dropped $10,000
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$229,999
$153
/ ft²
For Sale
3
Bed
2
Bath
1,500
ft²
$153
/ ft²
House, Updated 3 days ago
$468 / mo
Expenses
11.91%
Cap Rate
Real Estate Tax: 284.58 to 467.70
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$289,000
$202
/ ft²
For Sale
3
Bed
1
Bath
1,431
ft²
$202
/ ft²
House, Listed Jul 11th, 2020
$615 / mo
Expenses
8.87%
Cap Rate
Listed Jul 11th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$45,000
For Sale
Land, Listed Jul 10th, 2020
$108 / mo
Expenses
38.19%
Cap Rate
Bedrooms: 0 to -1
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$79,900
For Sale
Land, Updated 6 days ago
$93 / mo
Expenses
21.88%
Cap Rate
Price dropped $10,000
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$325,900
For Sale
5
Bed
3
Bath
House, Listed Jul 8th, 2020
$925 / mo
Expenses
20.53%
Cap Rate
Listed Jul 8th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$350,000
$175
/ ft²
For Sale
4
Bed
2
Bath
2,002
ft²
$175
/ ft²
House, Listed Jul 5th, 2020
$772 / mo
Expenses
9.69%
Cap Rate
Listed Jul 5th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$485,000
$197
/ ft²
For Sale
4
Bed
2
Bath
2,460
ft²
$197
/ ft²
House, Updated 1 week ago
$698 / mo
Expenses
7.18%
Cap Rate
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$359,000
$141
/ ft²
For Sale
3
Bed
2
Bath
2,548
ft²
$141
/ ft²
House, Listed Jul 2nd, 2020
$903 / mo
Expenses
6.01%
Cap Rate
Listed Jul 2nd, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$79,000
For Sale
1
Bed
1
Bath
House, Updated 2 weeks ago
$310 / mo
Expenses
19.6%
Cap Rate
Price dropped $20,000
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$329,900
For Sale
6
Bed
3
Bath
House, Listed Jul 3rd, 2020
$732 / mo
Expenses
24.62%
Cap Rate
Listed Jul 3rd, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$215,000
For Sale
3
Bed
1
Bath
House, Updated 1 week ago
$583 / mo
Expenses
12.1%
Cap Rate
Price dropped $10,000
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$339,000
For Sale
4
Bed
2
Bath
House, Listed Jul 2nd, 2020
$661 / mo
Expenses
10.76%
Cap Rate
Listed Jul 2nd, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$329,000
For Sale
3
Bed
1
Bath
House, Listed Jun 26th, 2020
$742 / mo
Expenses
7.14%
Cap Rate
Listed Jun 26th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$240,000
For Sale
3
Bed
1.5
Bath
House, Listed Jun 26th, 2020
$598 / mo
Expenses
10.51%
Cap Rate
Listed Jun 26th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$299,990
$240
/ ft²
For Sale
3
Bed
2
Bath
1,250
ft²
$240
/ ft²
House, Listed Jun 27th, 2020
$652 / mo
Expenses
8.39%
Cap Rate
Listed Jun 27th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$269,900
$120
/ ft²
For Sale
3
Bed
2.5
Bath
2,256
ft²
$120
/ ft²
House, Listed Jun 20th, 2020
$828 / mo
Expenses
8.32%
Cap Rate
Listed Jun 20th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$139,000
For Sale
3
Bed
1
Bath
House, Updated 2 weeks ago
$494 / mo
Expenses
19.48%
Cap Rate
Back on Market
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$359,900
$1,636
/ ft²
For Sale
4
Bed
3
Bath
220
ft²
$1,636
/ ft²
House, Listed Jun 24th, 2020
$810 / mo
Expenses
9.64%
Cap Rate
Listed Jun 24th, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$329,900
$248
/ ft²
For Sale
3
Bed
2
Bath
1,330
ft²
$248
/ ft²
House, Listed Jun 23rd, 2020
$750 / mo
Expenses
7.27%
Cap Rate
Listed Jun 23rd, 2020
Mastic Beach, Brookhaven
$295,000
For Sale
3
Bed
2
Bath
House, Listed Jun 21st, 2020
$699 / mo
Expenses
8.34%
Cap Rate
Listed Jun 21st, 2020
« Prev   |   Page 1 of 3 (58 Listings)   |   Next »
United States   ›   New York   ›   Fire Island   ›   11951
Largest Recent Price Drops
72 Shore Drive -$10,000 (-11.1%)
4 Sayville Rd -$10,000 (-4.6%)
15 Mallard Drive -$20,000 (-4.4%)
2 Woodchuck Court -$10,000 (-2.2%)
11951 currently has 48 residential homes for sale on the market. The median list price is $264,000 or $198 / ft². These listings range from $213,500 in the lower quartile to $329,900 in the upper quartile. The average home currently for sale in 11951 is around 56 years old and 0 ft². There are currently 3 studio, 2 one-bedroom, 5 two-bedroom, 22 three-bedroom, and 16 four+ bedroom listings for sale.
A more detailed breakdown of sizes and prices is below:
Median
Bedrooms Price Price / ft²
Studio $389,000 $0
1 BR $124,500 $0
2 BR $179,000 $190
3 BR $259,900 $198
4+ BR $327,450 $197

Out of the 48 listings that are currently on the market, there are 0 condos, 45 houses, 0 townhouses, and 3 multifamilies. Our real-time inventory refreshes every hour, so that you see the best new inventory available on the market.

This search area is located within 11951. 11951 has 13,959 residents in 4,769 households. The median age of this zipcode is 37.2 with a majority of inhabitants unmarried. At least 67.92% of those living in this zipcode currently own their homes. Roughly 0% of population here speak a language other than English at home.

The median income in this zipcode is $64,033, with an employment rate of 57.5%. It tends to take those living in 11951 an average of 39.0 minutes to get to work, with a majority commuting by car. Out of the total population of those 25 and older, 6.64% have a master’s or above, 10.29% have a bachelor’s, and 46.32% have a high school degree.

More broadly, 11951 is a part of Suffolk County, New York. Suffolk County, New York has around 1,498,130 residents, or 489,758 households with a median age of 40.9. Residents in this county have a median income of $90,128 and a home ownership rate of 79.46%.

Searching on Zillow 11951, Trulia, or Realtor.com? RealtyHop has the most comprehensive mortgage and property record data to help you make the best buying decision.

×
Maintenance
HOA dues, common charges, etc.
month
year
Property Taxes
Tax Year: 2018
month
year