51 JAY Street #PHA
About This Property
The complete offering terms are in an offering plan available from Sponsor. File No. CD14-0159.
Payment Calculator
Your Estimated Monthly Payment
Cap Rate Calculator
What does this mean?
Based on our analysis, the cap rate of this property is 1.25%. A negative cap rate indicates that the property might not be feasible as an income-producing asset. The median cap rate for a near zip code 11238 is 4.23%.
How much can I actually make?
Actual monthly rental income may vary between $4,760 and $7,140 depending on unit-specific characteristics. You can change the amount using the slider to further explore.
How is cap rate calculated?
Cap Rate = Net Operating Income (NOI) / Property Asset Value.
When calculating the cap rate, we assume 100% occupancy. Leverage (mortgage) is not considered.
Cap Rate provided by RealtyHop and RentHop, learn more about cap rate here.
Price History
| Date / Event | Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 2, 2019 | No longer available | - | |
| No longer available | |||
| Apr 2, 2019 | Price Decreased |
$4,650,000
↓ $60K
(1.3%) | |
| Price Decreased | |||
| Mar 18, 2019 | Sold | ||
| Sold | |||
| Feb 16, 2019 | In contract | - | |
| In contract | |||
| Nov 26, 2018 | No longer available | - | |
| No longer available | |||
Property Highlights
Comparables
Status
Price/ft²
Listed On
Sold On
Past Sales
| Date | Unit | Beds | Baths | Sqft | Price | Closed | Listed By |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
06/01/2026
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
866 ft²
|
$1,265,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
866 ft²
|
$1,265,000
10/01/2026
|
Scott Hustis
The Corcoran Group
| |
|
03/18/2026
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
894 ft²
|
$1,339,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
894 ft²
|
$1,225,000
-8.51%
08/25/2026
|
Tracie Golding
Compass
| |
|
10/23/2025
|
3 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1757 ft²
|
$2,417,000
3 Bed
3 Bath
1757 ft²
|
$2,365,000
-2.15%
02/25/2026
|
Marc Solomon
Compass
| |
|
09/15/2025
|
4 Bed
|
4 Bath
|
2973 ft²
|
$6,200,000
4 Bed
4 Bath
2973 ft²
|
$5,650,000
-8.87%
03/18/2026
|
Suzanne Koxvold
Compass
| |
|
03/12/2025
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1287 ft²
|
$1,795,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1287 ft²
|
$1,649,000
-8.13%
09/12/2025
|
Katya Diaz
Serhant LLC
| |
|
02/19/2025
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,150,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$1,848,500
-14.02%
12/19/2025
|
Linda VanderWoude
Halstead Property, LLC
| |
|
02/07/2025
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
665 ft²
|
$950,000
Studio
1 Bath
665 ft²
|
$995,000
+4.74%
06/26/2025
|
Monica Luque
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
| |
|
01/31/2025
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,175,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$1,830,000
-15.86%
10/29/2025
|
Deborah Zolan
Compass
| |
|
03/31/2024
|
3 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1664 ft²
|
$2,100,000
3 Bed
3 Bath
1664 ft²
|
$2,100,000
10/03/2024
|
Deborah Rieders
Corcoran Group
| |
|
02/16/2024
|
3 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
2421 ft²
|
$3,250,000
3 Bed
3 Bath
2421 ft²
|
$3,250,000
10/16/2024
|
Deborah Zolan
Compass
| |
|
07/17/2023
|
3 Bed
|
4 Bath
|
-
|
$2,899,000
3 Bed
4 Bath
|
-
-
|
Sari Eidelkind
Lucky to Live Here Realty
| |
|
03/27/2023
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1395 ft²
|
$1,950,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1395 ft²
|
$1,950,000
05/24/2023
|
Deborah Rieders
Corcoran Group
| |
|
02/21/2022
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1451 ft²
|
$2,175,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
1451 ft²
|
-
-
|
Deborah Zolan
Compass
| |
|
10/06/2021
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
664 ft²
|
$1,075,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
664 ft²
|
$1,040,000
-3.26%
05/18/2022
|
Kristi Ambrosetti
Sotheby's International Realty, Inc.
| |
|
05/27/2021
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1752 ft²
|
$2,995,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
1752 ft²
|
$2,795,000
-6.68%
09/16/2021
|
Deborah Zolan
Compass
| |
|
05/10/2021
|
4 Bed
|
5 Bath
|
3016 ft²
|
$5,950,000
4 Bed
5 Bath
3016 ft²
|
$5,500,890
-7.55%
10/25/2021
|
Deborah L Rieders
Corcoran Group
| |
|
03/09/2021
|
1 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
866 ft²
|
$1,275,000
1 Bed
2 Bath
866 ft²
|
$1,265,000
-0.78%
02/04/2022
|
Deborah Zolan
Compass
| |
|
02/21/2020
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$1,995,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$1,995,000
06/09/2021
|
Charles Homet
Compass
| |
|
02/12/2020
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$1,900,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$1,900,000
04/05/2021
|
Karen E Heyman Defontes
Sothebys International Realty
| |
|
06/03/2019
|
1 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
866 ft²
|
$1,385,000
1 Bed
2 Bath
866 ft²
|
$1,300,000
-6.14%
11/21/2019
|
Macie Barnes
Prevu Real Estate LLC
| |
|
02/18/2019
|
1 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
894 ft²
|
$1,499,000
1 Bed
2 Bath
894 ft²
|
$1,395,000
-6.94%
09/24/2019
|
Deborah Zolan
Compass
| |
|
07/17/2018
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,095,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,095,000
08/30/2018
|
Elissa Fitzig
Corcoran Group
| |
|
07/05/2018
|
3 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
3473 ft²
|
$4,500,000
3 Bed
3 Bath
3473 ft²
|
$4,500,000
10/01/2018
|
Richard Orenstein
Halstead Property, LLC
| |
|
03/15/2018
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1757 ft²
|
$2,675,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
1757 ft²
|
-
07/12/2018
|
Douglas Keith
The Corcoran Group
| |
|
11/02/2017
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
2009 ft²
|
$2,695,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
2009 ft²
|
$2,695,000
01/26/2018
|
Deborah Brener Zolan
Halstead Property, LLC
| |
|
02/13/2017
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
2008 ft²
|
$3,300,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
2008 ft²
|
$3,303,000
+0.09%
06/28/2017
|
Leasing Office
Halstead dba Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
| |
|
10/03/2016
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1695 ft²
|
$2,550,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1695 ft²
|
$2,599,590
+1.94%
03/02/2017
|
Leasing Office
Halstead dba Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
| |
|
06/15/2016
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
679 ft²
|
$1,050,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
679 ft²
|
$1,087,840
+3.60%
02/24/2017
|
Leasing Office
Halstead dba Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
| |
|
06/06/2016
|
4 Bed
|
4 Bath
|
2663 ft²
|
$4,650,000
4 Bed
4 Bath
2663 ft²
|
$4,650,000
03/18/2019
|
Richard Orenstein
Halstead Property, LLC
| |
|
06/06/2016
|
4 Bed
|
4.5 Bath
|
2973 ft²
|
$5,995,000
4 Bed
4.5 Bath
2973 ft²
|
$5,995,000
08/07/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
05/31/2016
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,155,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,155,000
06/19/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/28/2016
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1369 ft²
|
$2,075,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1369 ft²
|
$2,075,000
06/06/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/01/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1570 ft²
|
$2,225,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1570 ft²
|
$2,225,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/01/2015
|
3 Bed
|
4 Bath
|
1945 ft²
|
$2,825,000
3 Bed
4 Bath
1945 ft²
|
$2,825,000
04/12/2018
|
Richard Orenstein
Halstead Property, LLC
| |
|
09/09/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,250,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,250,000
08/07/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
07/28/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1570 ft²
|
$2,300,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1570 ft²
|
$2,300,000
06/08/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
07/28/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1287 ft²
|
$1,963,500
2 Bed
2 Bath
1287 ft²
|
$1,963,500
06/09/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
07/27/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1570 ft²
|
$2,257,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1570 ft²
|
$2,257,000
03/17/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
06/24/2015
|
2 Bed
|
4 Bath
|
1757 ft²
|
$2,795,000
2 Bed
4 Bath
1757 ft²
|
$2,585,000
-7.51%
07/12/2018
|
Julie Bienstock
Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
| |
|
04/16/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1931 ft²
|
$3,595,000
3 Bed
3 Bath
1931 ft²
|
$3,350,000
-6.82%
04/25/2018
|
Richard Orenstein
Halstead Property, LLC
| |
|
04/16/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
1899 ft²
|
$2,750,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
1899 ft²
|
$2,750,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
04/16/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,195,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,195,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
03/11/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1395 ft²
|
$2,035,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1395 ft²
|
$2,035,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
03/11/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1609 ft²
|
$2,205,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1609 ft²
|
$2,205,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
03/11/2015
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1664 ft²
|
$2,525,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
1664 ft²
|
$2,525,000
06/19/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
02/13/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1614 ft²
|
$2,425,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1614 ft²
|
$2,425,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
02/06/2015
|
1 Bed
|
1.5 Bath
|
894 ft²
|
$1,228,000
1 Bed
1.5 Bath
894 ft²
|
$1,228,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
02/06/2015
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1752 ft²
|
$2,695,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
1752 ft²
|
$2,695,000
06/19/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
02/06/2015
|
1 Bed
|
1.5 Bath
|
866 ft²
|
$1,215,000
1 Bed
1.5 Bath
866 ft²
|
$1,215,000
06/08/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
02/06/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1369 ft²
|
$1,950,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1369 ft²
|
$1,950,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
02/06/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1287 ft²
|
$2,025,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1287 ft²
|
$2,025,000
06/19/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/27/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1579 ft²
|
$2,265,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1579 ft²
|
$2,265,000
06/19/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/26/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
1945 ft²
|
$3,089,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
1945 ft²
|
$3,089,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/21/2015
|
1 Bed
|
1.5 Bath
|
894 ft²
|
$1,181,000
1 Bed
1.5 Bath
894 ft²
|
$1,181,000
03/07/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/21/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1287 ft²
|
$1,795,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1287 ft²
|
$1,795,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/21/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
1751 ft²
|
$2,475,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
1751 ft²
|
$2,475,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/21/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1395 ft²
|
$1,950,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1395 ft²
|
$1,950,000
06/19/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/21/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
2479 ft²
|
$3,525,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
2479 ft²
|
$3,525,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/21/2015
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1655 ft²
|
$2,375,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
1655 ft²
|
$2,375,000
06/19/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/21/2015
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
664 ft²
|
$875,000
Studio
1 Bath
664 ft²
|
$875,000
05/01/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/21/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1391 ft²
|
$1,795,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1391 ft²
|
$1,795,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/14/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,015,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,015,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
3 Bed
|
4 Bath
|
2023 ft²
|
$4,000,000
3 Bed
4 Bath
2023 ft²
|
$4,000,000
05/02/2018
|
Richard Orenstein
Halstead Property, LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
4 Bed
|
4.5 Bath
|
3016 ft²
|
$5,775,000
4 Bed
4.5 Bath
3016 ft²
|
$5,775,000
08/07/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
1839 ft²
|
$2,650,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
1839 ft²
|
$2,650,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1609 ft²
|
$2,275,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1609 ft²
|
$2,275,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
1 Bed
|
1.5 Bath
|
894 ft²
|
$1,400,000
1 Bed
1.5 Bath
894 ft²
|
$1,400,000
08/07/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
894 ft²
|
$965,000
Studio
1 Bath
894 ft²
|
$965,000
08/07/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
1053 ft²
|
$1,600,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
1053 ft²
|
$1,600,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
2005 ft²
|
$3,197,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
2005 ft²
|
$3,197,000
08/07/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
2421 ft²
|
$3,550,000
3 Bed
3 Bath
2421 ft²
|
$3,550,000
08/07/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1818 ft²
|
$2,595,000
3 Bed
3 Bath
1818 ft²
|
$2,595,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
1945 ft²
|
$3,190,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
1945 ft²
|
$3,190,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/13/2015
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
2005 ft²
|
$3,144,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
2005 ft²
|
$3,144,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/12/2015
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1664 ft²
|
$2,445,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
1664 ft²
|
$2,445,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/08/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,164,817
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,164,817
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/08/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,270,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,270,000
06/01/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/08/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,185,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,185,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
01/08/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$1,942,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$1,942,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/22/2014
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1306 ft²
|
$1,775,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1306 ft²
|
$1,775,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/19/2014
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1382 ft²
|
$2,148,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1382 ft²
|
$2,148,000
05/01/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/19/2014
|
3 Bed
|
4 Bath
|
2058 ft²
|
$4,250,000
3 Bed
4 Bath
2058 ft²
|
$4,250,000
08/13/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/19/2014
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1322 ft²
|
$1,740,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1322 ft²
|
-
-
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/19/2014
|
2 Bed
|
2.5 Bath
|
1306 ft²
|
$1,625,000
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
1306 ft²
|
$1,625,000
06/19/2017
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/19/2014
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
1664 ft²
|
$2,220,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
1664 ft²
|
$2,220,000
02/05/2021
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
| |
|
12/19/2014
|
3 Bed
|
3.5 Bath
|
1728 ft²
|
$2,350,000
3 Bed
3.5 Bath
1728 ft²
|
-
-
|
Leasing Office
AZ Realty NYC LLC
|
Building Info
Phone: 425-283-2930
Address: 335 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10017