4250 A1A S #N34
Payment Calculator
Your Estimated Monthly Payment
Cap Rate Calculator
What does this mean?
Based on our analysis, the cap rate of this property is 1.25%. A negative cap rate indicates that the property might not be feasible as an income-producing asset. The median cap rate for a near zip code 11238 is 4.23%.
How much can I actually make?
Actual monthly rental income may vary between $4,760 and $7,140 depending on unit-specific characteristics. You can change the amount using the slider to further explore.
How is cap rate calculated?
Cap Rate = Net Operating Income (NOI) / Property Asset Value.
When calculating the cap rate, we assume 100% occupancy. Leverage (mortgage) is not considered.
Cap Rate provided by RealtyHop and RentHop, learn more about cap rate here.
Price History
Property Highlights
Comparables
Status
Price/ft²
Listed On
Sold On
Past Sales
| Date | Unit | Beds | Baths | Sqft | Price | Closed | Listed By |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
07/16/2025
| |
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$400,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$375,000
-6.25%
03/30/2026
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
|
|
03/12/2022
| |
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$313,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
-
-
|
Anita Kay Huston
Coastal Realty & Property Management
|
|
06/18/2024
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
555 ft²
|
$299,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
555 ft²
|
-
-
|
Sarah Bell
Coldwell Banker Premier Properties
| |
|
04/10/2024
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$529,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Bonne (Barbara) Jones
Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices Florida Network Realty
| |
|
03/28/2024
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$329,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$329,000
05/13/2024
|
Sarah Bell
Coldwell Banker Premier Properties
| |
|
03/13/2024
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$480,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Ali Burchfield
Watson Realty Corp (A1A)
| |
|
02/29/2024
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1120 ft²
|
$499,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1120 ft²
|
$485,000
-2.98%
08/21/2024
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
01/31/2024
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$469,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Bruce Belmont
Sunshine Realty & Appraisal Services
| |
|
01/20/2024
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
729 ft²
|
$370,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
729 ft²
|
$345,000
-6.76%
07/25/2024
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
09/22/2023
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$549,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Bonne (Barbara) Jones
Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices Florida Network Realty
| |
|
09/20/2023
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$465,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Mary Burns
Crescent Beach Realty of St Augustine
| |
|
07/24/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$357,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
-
-
|
Sheila Clark, PA
Watson Realty Corp (A1A)
| |
|
06/07/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$320,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
-
-
|
Cathy Thomson
Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices Florida Network Realty
| |
|
05/30/2023
|
2 Bed
|
1.5 Bath
|
729 ft²
|
$379,000
2 Bed
1.5 Bath
729 ft²
|
-
-
|
Lawrence Kirkley
Ocean Breeze Property Management, LLC
| |
|
01/06/2023
|
2 Bed
|
4 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$475,000
2 Bed
4 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Ronald Tumlin
Crescent Beach Realty of St Augustine
| |
|
09/02/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$474,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$475,000
+0.02%
12/06/2022
|
Diane Vespucci
Tedo, Inc dba RE/MAX 100 Realty
| |
|
04/28/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$539,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$539,000
05/31/2022
|
Robert Sherno
Coastal Realty & Property Management
| |
|
04/20/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$549,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$544,500
-0.82%
06/15/2022
|
Geri Clay
Watson Realty Corp (A1A)
| |
|
04/20/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$549,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$540,000
-1.64%
06/24/2022
|
Geri Clay
Watson Realty Corp (A1A)
| |
|
04/05/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$499,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Bill Miller
Coldwell Banker Premier Properties
| |
|
03/28/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$549,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
S. Jill Mangum
CRESCENT BEACH REALTY OF ST AUGUSTINE
| |
|
03/30/2018
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
555 ft²
|
$149,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
555 ft²
|
$145,000
-3.27%
10/09/2018
|
Debbie Krantz
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
05/31/2016
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$235,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$225,000
-4.26%
10/04/2016
|
Greg Crum
Engel & Volkers St. Augustine
| |
|
05/21/2016
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
555 ft²
|
$139,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
555 ft²
|
$137,000
-1.44%
08/19/2016
|
Frank Perez-Andreu
Keller Williams - St. Augustine
| |
|
01/05/2016
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$143,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$139,000
-3.41%
05/02/2016
|
Teresa Jacalone
Watson Realty Corp (US1 South)
| |
|
11/05/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$249,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Greg Crum
Engel & Volkers St. Augustine
| |
|
10/13/2015
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
555 ft²
|
$139,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
555 ft²
|
$137,000
-2.07%
08/19/2016
|
AMBRA WAYNE
RE/MAX COAST 2 COAST
| |
|
09/18/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$269,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
MICHELE TRELA
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
06/01/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
729 ft²
|
$169,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
729 ft²
|
$163,000
-4.06%
10/05/2015
|
KAREN PEIL
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
02/21/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$230,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$215,000
-6.52%
04/23/2015
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
02/17/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
729 ft²
|
$160,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
729 ft²
|
$155,000
-3.13%
05/01/2015
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
01/27/2015
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$287,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$270,000
-5.92%
04/02/2015
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
08/26/2014
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$207,500
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$187,500
-9.64%
03/05/2015
|
BENJAMIN REICHENBACH JR
COMPLETE HOME REALTY, INC.
| |
|
08/24/2014
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1120 ft²
|
$250,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1120 ft²
|
$220,000
-12.00%
01/22/2015
|
Stefanie Bernstein
Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices Florida Network Realty
| |
|
02/06/2014
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$215,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$195,000
-9.30%
04/02/2015
|
LIANE STARK
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
01/31/2014
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
555 ft²
|
$115,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
555 ft²
|
$100,000
-13.04%
06/16/2014
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
11/21/2013
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$200,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$200,000
05/16/2014
|
KAREN PEIL
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
06/11/2013
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$235,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
05/17/2013
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$248,700
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$220,000
-11.54%
11/25/2013
|
MELISSA NELSON
LEE W. MCKEE, BROKER
| |
|
05/16/2013
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
555 ft²
|
$115,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
555 ft²
|
$95,000
-17.39%
08/22/2013
|
CHRISTINA WELCH
KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS SOUTHSIDE
| |
|
03/25/2013
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1120 ft²
|
$199,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1120 ft²
|
-
-
|
Greg Crum
Engel & Volkers St. Augustine
| |
|
01/23/2013
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$120,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$110,000
-8.33%
04/05/2013
|
KAREN PEIL
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
01/23/2013
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$123,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$119,000
-3.25%
05/07/2013
|
KAREN PEIL
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
11/05/2012
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$169,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$165,000
-2.37%
12/20/2012
|
THOMAS SCHEIRER
SCHEIRER REALTY, INC.
| |
|
10/18/2012
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
729 ft²
|
$140,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
729 ft²
|
$115,000
-17.86%
05/29/2013
|
THEODORE TYNDALL
DAVIDSON REALTY, INC.
| |
|
08/29/2012
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$229,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$210,000
-8.30%
04/10/2013
|
NANCY ASHE
THE ST JOHNS REALTY GROUP
| |
|
07/04/2012
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$125,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
-
-
|
Diane Grady
ENDLESS SUMMER REALTY
| |
|
05/19/2012
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$239,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$210,000
-12.46%
11/16/2012
|
Loise Trivette
Florida Homes Realty & Mortgage
| |
|
01/30/2012
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$168,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
MICHELE TRELA
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
12/19/2011
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$110,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$104,000
-5.45%
06/12/2012
|
Greg Crum
Engel & Volkers St. Augustine
| |
|
07/21/2011
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$105,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$120,000
+14.29%
05/21/2012
|
JAMES HAYS
SUNSHINE REALTY & VACATION RENTALS, LLC
| |
|
05/19/2011
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$175,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$168,000
-4.00%
05/04/2012
|
MICHELE TRELA
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
04/25/2011
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$100,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$95,000
-5.00%
04/26/2011
|
NON MLS
NON MLS
| |
|
12/24/2010
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$193,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
SHELBY SPINNEWEBER
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
11/02/2010
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1120 ft²
|
$199,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1120 ft²
|
$180,000
-9.55%
03/21/2011
|
ANN KING
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
09/24/2010
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$79,500
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$75,000
-5.66%
07/29/2011
|
CAROL ANN BENJAMIN
LIGHTHOUSE REALTY ASSOCIATES
| |
|
05/03/2010
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
753 ft²
|
$162,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
753 ft²
|
$155,000
-4.85%
12/30/2010
|
JAMES HUBBART
WATSON REALTY CORP
| |
|
12/01/2009
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
555 ft²
|
$129,700
1 Bed
1 Bath
555 ft²
|
-
-
|
BRAD LAYLAND
ENDLESS SUMMER REALTY
| |
|
11/20/2009
|
Studio
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$229,900
Studio
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
Teresa Mercurio
RE/MAX 100 Realty
| |
|
09/17/2009
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$205,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$186,000
-9.27%
05/13/2010
|
ANN KING
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
| |
|
05/20/2009
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$89,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$91,111
+1.35%
09/10/2009
|
NON MLS
NON MLS
| |
|
04/16/2009
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$249,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
CRIS GARRARD
CLG Real Estate LLC
| |
|
03/11/2009
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$310,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
AMANDA DANDY
KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS
| |
|
12/08/2008
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$89,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$82,000
-8.79%
04/22/2009
|
SCOTT LEHMBECK
REAL ESTATE ASSET DISPOSITION CORP.
| |
|
10/15/2008
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$249,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
Jeanette Smith
WATSON REALTY CORP
| |
|
08/15/2008
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
676 ft²
|
$199,999
1 Bed
1 Bath
676 ft²
|
$135,900
-32.05%
07/20/2009
|
Larry Barber
VANGUARD REALTY INC.
| |
|
05/02/2008
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$299,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Jeff Schnittker
WATSON REALTY CORP
| |
|
04/14/2008
|
Studio
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$259,900
Studio
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
Jeanette Smith
WATSON REALTY CORP
| |
|
11/22/2007
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$399,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
SHELBY SPINNEWEBER
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
03/14/2008
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$329,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
SHELBY SPINNEWEBER
REMAX MARKET FORCE
| |
|
04/25/2007
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$499,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Regina Stevens
MLS REALTY
| |
|
02/04/2007
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$339,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$320,000
-5.60%
08/30/2007
|
PATRICK GREEN
THE SIMS CHRISTOPHER GROUP
| |
|
08/16/2006
| |
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$359,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Jeanette Smith
WATSON REALTY CORP
|
|
08/04/2006
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$469,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Elizabeth Ponte
PROFESSIONAL REALTY NETWORK IN
| |
|
06/06/2006
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$365,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
CYNTHIA D HACKNEY
OLD SOUTH MORTGAGE & REALTY CO
| |
|
04/20/2006
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$299,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$282,000
-5.97%
06/19/2007
|
Jeff Schnittker
WATSON REALTY CORP
| |
|
03/16/2006
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$329,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$325,000
-1.49%
05/08/2006
|
Geri M Clay
WATSON REALTY CORP
| |
|
03/14/2006
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$454,500
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
CAROL ANN BENJAMIN
LIGHTHOUSE REALTY ASSOCIATES
| |
|
02/01/2006
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$334,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
Debby Craggs
RE/MAX UNLIMITED
| |
|
09/15/2005
| |
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$219,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$209,000
-4.96%
10/31/2005
|
ANN WALLACE
AGNES ANN WALLACE, BROKER
|
|
12/22/2005
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
729 ft²
|
$319,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
729 ft²
|
-
-
|
WADE COLEMAN
FIVE STAR REALTY SERVICES, INC
| |
|
12/01/2004
|
2 Bed
|
3 Bath
|
720 ft²
|
$250,000
2 Bed
3 Bath
720 ft²
|
$250,000
12/03/2004
|
NON MLS
NON MLS
| |
|
09/15/2004
| |
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$174,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$173,000
-1.09%
11/19/2004
|
MARIE MITCHELL
CENTURY 21 ST AUGUSTINE PROPERTIES
|
|
06/21/2004
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
676 ft²
|
$164,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
676 ft²
|
$164,910
+0.01%
06/29/2004
|
Peggy Gachet
Watson Realty Corp (A1A)
| |
|
10/29/2003
| |
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$155,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
-
-
|
MARIE MITCHELL
CENTURY 21 ST AUGUSTINE PROPERTIES
|
|
07/22/2003
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
687 ft²
|
$144,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
687 ft²
|
$139,000
-4.07%
11/26/2003
|
Peggy Gachet
Watson Realty Corp (A1A)
| |
|
06/07/2003
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$235,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$230,000
-2.13%
09/17/2003
|
RAQUEL LLOYD
MAGNOLIA PROPERTIES
| |
|
05/21/2003
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$234,700
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
MARIE MITCHELL
CENTURY 21 ST AUGUSTINE PROPERTIES
| |
|
04/23/2003
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
729 ft²
|
$159,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
729 ft²
|
$159,000
09/04/2003
|
PEGGY GACHET
WATSON REALTY CORP
| |
|
02/20/2003
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$251,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
$215,900
-14.29%
05/16/2003
|
MARIE MITCHELL
CENTURY 21 ST AUGUSTINE PROPERTIES
| |
|
09/29/2000
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1044 ft²
|
$169,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1044 ft²
|
-
-
|
11105 11105
REALTY CHANNEL NORTH FLORI
|
Building Info
About Butler Beach
Similar Homes for Sale
Currently no similar homes aroundNearby Rentals
$1,700 /mo
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 993 ft²
$2,500 /mo
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,016 ft²
Phone: 425-283-2930
Address: 335 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10017