When was property at 40 McCarter Avenue built and last sold?

The property at 40 McCarter Avenue was built in 1952 and last sold on Jun 19, 2018 for $789,000.

How much is this home worth?

The estimated value of the home located at 40 McCarter Avenue is $1,518,625.

What are some comparable homes to 40 McCarter Avenue?

There are currently no comparable homes to 40 McCarter Avenue.

Fair Haven

07704

Fair Haven

40 Mccarter Avenue

Sold on Jun 8, 2026

Map

$1,605,000

● House - Off Market

40 Mccarter Avenue

Fair Haven, NJ 07704

4 Beds

3 Baths

2,680 Ft²

$8,871

Est. Monthly

About This Property

Spacious 4/5 BR home located in the heart of Fair Haven offering the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. Main level Family Room with Gas Fireplace opens to the Updated Eat-in Kitchen and Multi-purpose room overlooking the backyard. Second level with 3 BRs and staircase to a 4th spacious BR with private deck. Lower level with optional 5th bedroom or wonderful home office plus bonus room perfect for the home gym or playroom. 3 new Full Baths. Basement is partially finished offering additional rec space and a large storage room. Private yard featuring an inground heated pool and perennial gardens. HW floors, home Generator. Close to top-rated schools, parks, local shops and just a quick drive to the Jersey Shore Beaches and transportation to NYC. Driveway can accomodate 4 Cars and in addition, plenty of street parking. New Tankless Hot Water Heater. Central Air in most of the home with newer mini-splits in top bedroom and basement.

Unit Size

2,680 Ft²

Days on Market

82 days

Land Size

Price per sqft

$559

Property Type

House

Property Taxes

$1,511

HOA Dues

Year Built

1952

Payment Calculator

Cap Rate Calculator

Last updated: 4 months ago (MOMLS #22606648)

Price History

Date / Event	Date	Event
Jun 8, 2026	Sold	Premium
Sold
Mar 28, 2026	In contract	-
In contract
Mar 15, 2026	Listed by Coldwell Banker Realty	$1,499,000
Listed by Coldwell Banker Realty
Jun 22, 2018	Sold	Premium
Sold
Feb 19, 2018	Listed by Gloria Nilson & Co. Real Estate	$799,999
Listed by Gloria Nilson & Co. Real Estate

	We all know how important location is when buying real estate. Set in the characteristic community of Fair Haven this home has an idyllic location plus so much more! 4/5 bedrooms, 3 full baths with recent renovations including a new roof, siding, kitchen and much more. Property features a stunning yard with heated in ground pool and perennial gardens. Great schools, convenient commuter access and close to parks, beaches and downtown Red Bank. It's time to make 40 Mccarter in Fair Haven your next move!

Property Highlights

Garage

Air Conditioning

Fireplace

Building Info

Overview

General

Year Built: 1952

Effective Year Built: 1952
Building Count: 1
Total Rooms: 8
Bedroom Count: 5
Bathroom Count: 3
Full Bathrooms: 3
Partial Bathrooms: 3
Building Condition: 6
Building Quality: 0
Construction Type: 11
Building Style: 41
Exterior Walls Type: 19
Interior Walls Type: 0
Roof Shape Type: 1
Roof Cover Type: 20
Floor Count: 200
Living Units: 1
Floor Cover: 0
Basement Type: 9
Basement Area: 736
Garage Type: 2
Garage Square Area: 336
Parking Space Count: 1
Patio Type: 0
Porch Type: 7
Pool Type: 10

Dimensions

Lot Size Square Feet: 9,800

Lot Size Depth Feet: 1,400
Lot Size Frontage Feet: 700
Total Building Area: 2,680
Building Area: 2,680
Building Area Measurement: L

Heating and Cooling

Fireplace Count: 1

Air Conditioning: 13
Heating: 0
Heated Square Feet: 2,680
Heating Fuel Type: 0

Utilities

Sewer System: 5

Water Service: 6

Building

Building Type: 0

Property Class: R
Land Acres: 0000000225
Standard Land Use Code: 1001
County Land Use Code: 2

Neighborhood

School District Name: Fair Haven Borough School District

Census Tract: 803700

Zoning

Zoning: SF10

Geography

Assessors Map Reference: TAX MAP 3

District: 14
Parcel: 14 00077-0000-00047
Block: 77
Lot: 47
Municipality: FAIR HAVEN BORO
Latitude: 40.3577
Longitude: -74.0343

Address

Full Address: 40 Mccarter Ave

Address - House Number: 40
Address - Street Name: Mccarter
Address - Suffix Type: Ave
State: NJ
City Name: Fair Haven
Carrier Code: C018
4-Digit Zip Code: 3425
Zip Code: 07704

Valuation

Tax

Tax Year: 2023

Tax Amount: $1,695,041

Appraisal Valuation

Standard Deviation: 0.1882

Valuation Date: Apr 03, 2024
Confidence Score: 75
Final Value: 1,369,464
High Value: 1,627,283
Low Value: 1,111,644

Market Valuation

Market Total Value: $1,076,900

Market Land Value: $475,900
Market Improvement Value: $601,000

Assessments Valuation

Assessed Year: 2023

Assessed Total Value: $1,076,900
Assessed Land Value: $475,900
Assessed Improvements Value: $601,000

Sales

Current Sale Contract Date: Jun 19, 2018

Current Sale Recording Date: Jul 16, 2018
Current Sale Price:

Premium
Current Sale Document Type: 27
Current Sale Input Document Number: 2018068867
Previous Sale Recording Date: Oct 05, 2011
Previous Sale Contract Date: Sep 26, 2011
Previous Sale Amount: $525,000
Previous Sale Document Type: 27

Last Sale Mortgage

First Mortgage Lender:

Premium

First Mortgage Transaction Date:

Premium
First Mortgage Loan Amount:

Premium
First Mortgage Terms:

Premium
First Mortgage Loan Type:

Premium
First Mortgage Loan Due Date:

Premium

Financing

First Mortgage Financing Type: FIX

Data used for valuation calculations is provided by RealtyHop, and other third party sources

Request mortgage information redaction

Comparables

About Fair Haven

Stats & Trends

Median Asking:

$1,499,000

Sale Price/ft²

$704

Above Asking

0.00%

Average Days on Market

Average Home Size

2355 ft²

Average Home Age

23.4 years

Currently For Sale

11 Listings

Based on RH Advisors, Inc. calculations of home data from MLS and/or public records.

Similar Homes for Sale

Currently no similar homes around

Nearby Rentals

Unit for rent at 44 Marion Street, Red Bank, NJ, 07701

$3,600 /mo

2 Beds
1 Bath

44 Marion Street #9, Red Bank, NJ, 07701 Listing by Lillian LoRusso

Unit for rent at 321 Spring Street, Red Bank, NJ, 07701

$3,600 /mo

2 Beds
1 Bath

321 Spring Street #8, Red Bank, NJ, 07701 Listing by Katherine Narson

Unit for rent at 129 Rumson Road, Little Silver, NJ, 07739

$5,975 /mo

4 Beds
1 Bath

129 Rumson Road, Little Silver, NJ, 07739 Listing by C. Catherine Swett

Rentals Near You

Click here to view more rentals in the neighborhood.

Listed by: Kim L Spector, Coldwell Banker Realty
Last Updated: 4 months ago
Data Source: MOMMLS, MLS# 22606648

IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed.