When was property at 3458 Anglin Drive built and last sold?

The property at 3458 Anglin Drive was built in 1983 and last sold on Jun 8, 2016 for $541,000.

How much is this home worth?

The estimated value of the home located at 3458 Anglin Drive is $2,620,950.

What are some comparable homes to 3458 Anglin Drive?

There are currently no comparable homes to 3458 Anglin Drive.

Sarasota

34242

Bay Island Park

3458 ANGLIN DRIVE

Map

$2,595,000

● House - For Sale

3458 ANGLIN DRIVE

SARASOTA, FL 34242

4 Beds

2 Baths, 1 Half Bath

2,513 Ft²

$14,381

Est. Monthly

About This Property

Welcome to Bay Island, ideally positioned on the north end of Siesta Key, where island living meets exceptional convenience. Just moments from Siesta Beach, Siesta Key Village, and downtown Sarasota's waterfront dining and cultural offerings-with easy access on and off the island-this elevated Key West-style residence is set across a rare double lot, an uncommon offering on Siesta Key. Fully renovated in late 2019, the home features new siding, roof, electrical, plumbing, irrigation, hurricane-rated windows and French doors, and two HVAC systems. It has since been further enhanced with premium retractable invisible screens on all French doors, kitchen and bath refinements, and a whole-house water filtration system, along with additional upgrades that reflect its continued care and quality. The open-concept floor plan is filled with natural light, highlighted by vaulted ceilings, LVP flooring, and a natural gas fireplace. Multiple covered terraces extend the living space outdoors, reinforcing the home's relaxed coastal design. The kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, centered around a large quartzite island with extensive drawer storage and pull-out shelving. A full Thermador appliance package includes a gas range, refrigerator and freezer columns, and dishwasher. Soft-close cabinetry and thoughtful storage solutions provide both function and efficiency. French doors open to an oversized covered deck overlooking mature tropical landscaping. The well-sized owner's suite is located on the main living level and includes a walk-in closet and a private en-suite bathroom featuring a double vanity and large walk-in shower. A den on this level offers flexibility and can easily serve as a fourth bedroom or home office. Upstairs, two generously sized guest bedrooms share a newly appointed bathroom and enjoy access to a third-level terrace ideal for sunset views. Outdoor living sets this property apart. The double lot creates an expansive backyard with a recently resurfaced pool, travertine decking, and multiple covered terraces-an uncommon offering on Siesta Key. The additional lot provides flexibility for future enhancements while preserving privacy and open space.

Unit Size

2,513 Ft²

Days on Market

171 days

Land Size

0.33 acres

Price per sqft

$1,033

Property Type

House

Property Taxes

$1,638

HOA Dues

Year Built

1983

Listed By

Barbara May

[email protected]

MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

Fred Sassen

[email protected]

MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

Payment Calculator

Cap Rate Calculator

Last updated: 6 months ago (Stellar MLS #A4683447)

Price History

Date / Event	Date	Event
Feb 20, 2026	Listed by MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY	$2,595,000
Listed by MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY
Aug 28, 2024	Sold	Premium
Sold
Jul 23, 2024	In contract	-
In contract
Jun 26, 2024	Price Decreased	$2,500,000 ↓ $300K (10.7%)
Price Decreased
May 29, 2024	Relisted	$2,800,000
Relisted
May 28, 2024	In contract	-
In contract
Apr 28, 2024	Price Decreased	$2,800,000 ↓ $150K (5.1%)
Price Decreased
Mar 29, 2024	Price Decreased	$2,950,000 ↓ $50K (1.7%)
Price Decreased
Mar 11, 2024	Listed by VETERANS REALTY INC.	$3,000,000
Listed by VETERANS REALTY INC.

	Welcome to Bay Island, the Gateway to Siesta Key! This beautiful home is the beginning of enjoying the Siesta Key lifestyle. With 3500 sf under roof you can enjoy all the amenities Siesta has to offer. The tropical landscaping of the property alone will make you feel like you are on vacation. The home sits on 2 lots -located on both Anglin Drive and Flamingo Drive - offers you complete and total privacy. The open air pool is surrounded by beautiful travertine, a large area for entertaining, and covered decks on the front and back of the second level. The back deck is completely tiled and has ceiling fans as well as wired for outdoor speakers. It truly feels like you are at a fine resort! Everything from the inside out is just 4 years old. Arrive through a beautiful entryway with new staircase and new LVP flooring throughout. When you turn the corner you are welcomed into an open floor plan that is filled with lots of natural light. The living room has a new natural gas fireplace that adds a beautiful ambiance and a touch of elegance. The kitchen boasts an expansive quartzite island and features all Thermador appliances - including a gas stove, fridge and freezer columns and a dishwasher. The island is filled with storage drawers and undercounter pull out shelving. All cabinet drawers and doors are soft close. Walk out the new French doors onto an oversized, covered deck and take in the beautiful tropical landscaping. The owner's suite is located on the main living level and comes equipped with a spacious walk-in closet, a beautiful bath with a 10' double vanity and large walk-in shower. The main living area also features a nice cozy den that can easily be turned into a 4th bedroom. Located on the third level are two very large guest rooms as well as a fully remodeled bathroom. At the end of the day step out onto the third-floor deck and enjoy spectacular sunsets in your own home! The home as of late 2019 has all new siding, new roof, electrical and plumbing and irrigation. All the French doors and windows are hurricane rated. There are two new HVAC units as well. This home is perfect for weekly short term rentals within Sarasota City limits. Living on the North end of the island is perfect for a quick getaway to the beautiful chrystal sands of Siesta beach or a night in the village. Take a short trip over the bridge and enjoy all the amenities that Sarasota has to offer. You are close to downtown, Selby Gardens or shopping at the beautiful St. Armands.
Jun 8, 2016	Sold	Premium
Sold

Property Highlights

Garage

Air Conditioning

Fireplace

Parking Details

Has Garage

Attached Garage

Has Open Parking

Parking Features: Driveway, Garage Door Opener

Garage Spaces: 2

Interior Details

Half Bathrooms: 1

Full Bathrooms: 2

Interior Features: Ceiling Fan(s), Crown Molding, High Ceilings, Open Floorplan, Stone Counters, Vaulted Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Eating Space In Kitchen, Kitchen/Family Room Combo, Living Room/Dining Room Combo, Skylight(s), Solid Wood Cabinets, Thermostat, Window Treatments

Appliances: Convection Oven, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Freezer, Gas Water Heater, Microwave, Range, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Washer, Water Purifier

Flooring Type: Carpet, Luxury Vinyl

Door Features: French Doors

Laundry Features: Inside, Laundry Room

Rooms: 7

Has Fireplace

Fireplace Features: Gas, Living Room

Exterior Details

Square Footage: 2513

Square Footage Source: $0

Property Condition: Completed

Architectural Style: Elevated, Florida, Key West

Year Built: 1983

Building Area Total: 6151

Levels: Three Or More

Building Area Units: Square Feet

Window Features: Storm Window(s)

Construction Materials: Block, HardiPlank Type, Wood Siding

Patio and Porch Features: Covered, Front Porch, Rear Porch

Pool Features: Gunite, Heated, In Ground, Salt Water, Lighting

Pool is Private

Lot Features: City Lot, Landscaped, FloodZone, Oversized Lot

Lot Size Area: 14400

Lot Size Units: Square Feet

Lot Size Acres: 0.33

Lot Size Square Feet: 14400

Lot Size Dimensions: 80 x 180

Tax Lot: 5

Water Source: Public

Financial Details

Tax Annual Amount: $19,659

Lease Considered: Yes

Utilities Details

Cooling Type: Central Air, Multi Units

Heating Type: Central

Sewer : Public Sewer

Building Info

Overview

General

Year Built: 1983

Effective Year Built: 2013
Building Count: 1
Total Rooms: 10
Bedroom Count: 3
Bathroom Count: 3
Full Bathrooms: 2
Partial Bathrooms: 3
Building Condition: 6
Building Quality: 9
Construction Type: 17
Building Style: 0
Exterior Walls Type: 18
Interior Walls Type: 3
Roof Shape Type: 1
Roof Cover Type: 15
Floor Count: 300
Living Units: 1
Floor Cover: 9
Basement Type: 0
Basement Area: 0
Garage Type: 1
Garage Square Area: 525
Parking Space Count: 3
Patio Type: 5
Porch Type: 102
Pool Type: 8
Location Influence Type: 113

Dimensions

Lot Size Square Feet: 14,400

Lot Size Depth Feet: 1,800
Lot Size Frontage Feet: 800
Total Building Area: 3,038
Gross Building Area: 3,038
Building Area: 2,513
Building Area Measurement: L

Heating and Cooling

Fireplace Count: 1

Air Conditioning: 1
Heating: 3
Heated Square Feet: 2,513
Heating Fuel Type: 0

Utilities

Sewer System: 1

Water Service: 2

Building

Building Type: 0

Property Class: R
Subdivision: BAY ISLAND PARK
Land Acres: 0000000331
Standard Land Use Code: 1001
County Land Use Code: 0100
State Land Use Code: 001
Legal Description 1: THE S 80 FT OF LOTS 5 & 6 BLK A BAY ISLAND PARK

Neighborhood

School District Name: Sarasota County School District

School Tax School District: T02 T02D A055
Census Tract: 001903

Zoning

Zoning: RSF2

Geography

Assessors Map Reference: 21

Account Number: 2019100041
Subdivision Tract Number: 897
Parcel: 2019-10-0041
Block: A
Lot: 5,6
Meridian: SEC 36 TWN 36S RNG 17E
Municipality: CITY OF SARASOTA
Latitude: 27.3027
Longitude: -82.5536

Address

Full Address: 3458 Anglin Dr

Address - House Number: 3458
Address - Street Name: Anglin
Address - Suffix Type: Dr
State: FL
City Name: Sarasota
Carrier Code: C028
4-Digit Zip Code: 1002
Zip Code: 34242

Valuation

Tax

Total Area: 5,313

Tax Year: 2023
Tax Amount: $1,030,109
Tax Rate Code Area: 0200

Appraisal Valuation

Standard Deviation: 0.193

Valuation Date: Mar 06, 2024
Confidence Score: 74
Final Value: 1,694,666
High Value: 2,021,881
Low Value: 1,367,450

Market Valuation

Market Total Value: $1,253,200

Market Land Value: $641,000
Market Improvement Value: $612,200

Assessments Valuation

Assessed Year: 2023

Assessed Total Value: $697,564

Exemptions

Homeowner Exemption: Yes

Sales

Current Sale Contract Date: Jun 08, 2016

Current Sale Recording Date: Jun 08, 2016
Current Sale Price:

Premium
Current Sale Document Type: 71
Current Sale Input Document Number: 2016071345

Data used for valuation calculations is provided by RealtyHop, and other third party sources

Request mortgage information redaction

Comparables

About Bay Island Park

Stats & Trends

Median Asking:

$1,544,450

Sale Price/ft²

$555

Below Asking

0.03%

Average Days on Market

Average Home Size

2513 ft²

Average Home Age

43 years

Currently For Sale

1 Listings

Based on RH Advisors, Inc. calculations of home data from MLS and/or public records.

Similar Homes for Sale

Currently no similar homes around

Nearby Rentals

Unit for rent at 2232 Pine Terrace, FL, 34231

$8,000 /mo

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,557 ft²

2232 Pine Terrace, FL, 34231 Listing by Andy Moore

Unit for rent at 5159 Oakmont Place, SARASOTA, FL, 34242

$10,000 /mo

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,953 ft²

5159 Oakmont Place, SARASOTA, FL, 34242 Listing by Scott Nold

Unit for rent at 5400 Ocean Boulevard, SARASOTA, FL, 34242

$9,500 /mo

1 Bed
1 Bath
936 ft²

5400 Ocean Boulevard #1002, SARASOTA, FL, 34242 Listing by Sean Altice

Rentals Near You

Click here to view more rentals in the neighborhood.

Listed by: Barbara May
MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY
Last Updated: 6 months ago
Data Source: Stellar MLS, MLS# A4683447

IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed.