Nothing here has been decided yet, and that is the best thing about it. The plan is drawn, the 2.26 acres are ready, and the neighborhood around it is all striking custom homes with real space between them, not a corner cut on a single one. This is the side of Goshen that still feels like country, and everyone on this road went looking for exactly that. Every choice that normally gets made for you a year before you ever walked in is open, starting with where the fireplace goes in the room you will live in most.

That room is 14 by 20 and opens all the way to the second floor, so light drops in from two stories of windows and somebody laughing downstairs can be heard from the top of the stairs. The covered porch across the front runs 23 feet, the kind of depth that slows people down on their way to the door. Inside, 9 foot ceilings carry the whole first floor. The dining room stands a step off the kitchen without being in it, which is how a dinner that started at 6 is still going at 10, and there is an office with a door that actually closes, which you will appreciate on the loud days.

Behind the kitchen the plans mark a hidden pantry, 13 feet of shelves out of sight, and you will understand the point of it the first time company arrives early.

Upstairs the primary bedroom is 17 by 13 under a tray ceiling, and the walk-in beside it comes in at nearly 13 by 12, larger than plenty of bedrooms and yours to fit out however you please. Two more bedrooms line the hall. The fourth stretches 22 feet, long enough to become a studio, a guest space nobody wants to give up, or the spot where the drums finally live.

The village is 5 minutes away and it is a good one. Saturday mornings there is the market. Dinner is Limoncello at the Orange Inn when you want white tablecloths, or Franzel on West Main when the answer is schnitzel and a beer, or the Stagecoach Inn when the point is to sit at the bar and know everybody. The Heritage Trail runs right through town, which is how a walk after work turns into 12 miles on a bike by Sunday. Fourth of July weekend, the Great American Weekend fills with 150 craft vendors and much of the county, and the harness track opens for its meets. Route 17 is minutes out, Campbell Hall is the close station for the train, and Manhattan is 60 miles east on the days that call for it.

Living here will be simple in the ways that count. A 2-zone heat pump and central air take care of February and August, spray foam in the exterior walls keeps the bills reasonable, laundry is on the first floor, and the garage is insulated and heated so January never shuts it down. The basement walks out at grade, unfinished for now, waiting for whatever you eventually decide belongs down there.

New Gen has been building in Orange County for decades, so the part left to you is the fun part. You will stand on a bare subfloor pointing at where the windows should land, and a season later you will be standing in the finished room knowing every inch of it was your call. Very few people ever get to say that about the place they come home to.