This 1800s Colonial was born as a gathering place and has been beautifully reborn for today. Formerly known as the Hainesville Inn, this landmark Sandyston property sits on 1.51 level acres and blends restored historic character with modern comfort. Inside, high ceilings and brand new hardwood floors set the tone, leading to a renovated kitchen with top tier appliances, leather finished counters, custom cabinetry, breakfast bar, center island and pantry. The original bar, once said to be a gathering place for Yankee legend Babe Ruth, has been thoughtfully restored as the home's signature centerpiece. Formal living and dining spaces extend the main level, along with a powder room for added convenience. The second and third floors offer six spacious bedrooms, four full baths and a custom laundry room with built ins, shelving and folding space. The full basement offers excellent storage with Bilko door access and room for recreation, hobbies or future vision. Outside, enjoy the welcoming front porch, upper balcony, back patio, in ground pool, generous parking and open level grounds. Minutes from Stokes State Forest, High Point State Park, the Appalachian Trail, Flatbrook trout fishing, lake recreation, the Delaware River, Milford, Port Jervis Train Station, Route 206, Route 84 and Route 23, this property offers history, lifestyle, convenience and possibility, with potential commercial use as part of Hainesville Village. A rare opportunity for new history to be made.