3121 Middletown Road #1M
About This Property
The manager has listed the unit size as 1306 square feet.
Payment Calculator
Your Estimated Monthly Payment
Cap Rate Calculator
What does this mean?
Based on our analysis, the cap rate of this property is 1.25%. A negative cap rate indicates that the property might not be feasible as an income-producing asset. The median cap rate for a near zip code 11238 is 4.23%.
How much can I actually make?
Actual monthly rental income may vary between $4,760 and $7,140 depending on unit-specific characteristics. You can change the amount using the slider to further explore.
How is cap rate calculated?
Cap Rate = Net Operating Income (NOI) / Property Asset Value.
When calculating the cap rate, we assume 100% occupancy. Leverage (mortgage) is not considered.
Cap Rate provided by RealtyHop and RentHop, learn more about cap rate here.
Price History
| Date / Event | Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feb 23, 2021 | Sold | ||
| Sold | |||
| Oct 11, 2020 | No longer available | - | |
| No longer available | |||
| Oct 8, 2020 | Relisted | $250,000 | |
| Relisted | |||
| Aug 11, 2020 | No longer available | - | |
| No longer available | |||
| May 7, 2020 | Price Decreased |
$250,000
↓ $69K
(21.6%) | |
| Price Decreased | |||
Property Highlights
Comparables
Status
Price/ft²
Listed On
Sold On
Past Sales
| Date | Unit | Beds | Baths | Sqft | Price | Closed | Listed By |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
03/20/2026
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$199,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$199,000
05/27/2026
|
Veronica Muth
Charles Rutenberg, LLC
| |
|
11/04/2025
| |
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
700 ft²
|
$180,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
700 ft²
|
-
-
|
Veronica Muth
Charles Rutenberg, LLC
|
|
09/30/2025
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
700 ft²
|
$225,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
700 ft²
|
$180,000
-20.00%
02/27/2026
|
Israel Sanchez
Morris Park Realty Group
| |
|
09/25/2025
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1200 ft²
|
$345,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1200 ft²
|
-
-
|
Israel Sanchez
Morris Park Realty Group
| |
|
08/11/2025
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$155,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$156,000
+0.65%
09/29/2025
|
Veronica Muth
Charles Rutenberg, LLC
| |
|
08/10/2025
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
660 ft²
|
$145,000
Studio
1 Bath
660 ft²
|
-
-
|
Thomas Consaga
RE/MAX Ace Realty
| |
|
07/28/2025
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1200 ft²
|
$300,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1200 ft²
|
$289,000
-3.67%
02/10/2026
|
Sandra Glaser SRES E-PRO MRP PSA S
Highlite Homes Realty Corp
| |
|
06/16/2025
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$180,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$180,000
03/19/2026
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
02/07/2025
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
700 ft²
|
$145,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
700 ft²
|
$156,000
+7.59%
04/25/2025
|
Kimberly Arias Salazar
Keller Williams Realty Group
| |
|
12/17/2024
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
700 ft²
|
$170,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
700 ft²
|
$155,000
-8.82%
11/26/2025
|
Tiffany French
Clarke Realty
| |
|
12/01/2024
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1250 ft²
|
$330,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1250 ft²
|
-
-
|
Sandra Glaser SRES E-PRO MRP PSA S
Highlite Homes Realty Corp
| |
|
07/14/2024
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
600 ft²
|
$125,000
Studio
1 Bath
600 ft²
|
$125,000
12/13/2024
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
05/24/2024
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
755 ft²
|
$169,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
755 ft²
|
$165,000
-2.37%
10/29/2024
|
James A. Andrews
Coldwell Banker American Homes
| |
|
04/14/2024
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1250 ft²
|
$299,900
2 Bed
2 Bath
1250 ft²
|
$310,000
+3.37%
10/16/2024
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
04/06/2024
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$179,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Marc Windheuser
Keller Williams Rlty Landmark
| |
|
02/04/2024
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$189,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$189,900
04/30/2024
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
01/02/2024
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$125,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
12/07/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
825 ft²
|
$170,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
825 ft²
|
$180,000
+5.88%
01/03/2025
|
Ruth Burney
Hollingsworth Real Estate Grp.
| |
|
11/09/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
660 ft²
|
$165,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
660 ft²
|
$155,000
-6.06%
06/13/2024
|
Jose L. Reyes
Exit Realty Search
| |
|
10/31/2023
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$320,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
Socorro Fernandez
Exit Realty Achieve
| |
|
10/19/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
680 ft²
|
$145,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
680 ft²
|
$142,000
-2.07%
05/17/2024
|
Eugene Branca
Century 21 Kafcos Realty
| |
|
08/29/2023
|
2 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
1000 ft²
|
$304,999
2 Bed
1 Bath
1000 ft²
|
$300,000
-1.64%
01/17/2024
|
Mary Ackermann
Morris Park Realty Group
| |
|
08/28/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
700 ft²
|
$145,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
700 ft²
|
$160,000
+10.34%
08/20/2024
|
Albert Posillico
Keller Williams Realty Group
| |
|
08/02/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$189,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$184,900
-2.17%
11/30/2023
|
Merit Nezaj
Bajraktari Realty Group LLC
| |
|
07/05/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$142,500
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Angelo Gonzalez
Realty By The Park
| |
|
05/16/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$175,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$165,000
-5.71%
01/19/2024
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
05/03/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$170,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
James A. Andrews
Coldwell Banker American Homes
| |
|
04/06/2023
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$140,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
$138,000
-1.43%
04/18/2023
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
03/21/2023
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$175,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$170,000
-2.86%
03/04/2024
|
Marc Windheuser
Keller Williams Rlty Landmark
| |
|
02/28/2023
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$320,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
$305,000
-4.69%
10/03/2023
|
William Chester
Morris Park Realty Group
| |
|
01/27/2023
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1100 ft²
|
$225,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1100 ft²
|
$225,000
09/17/2024
|
Steven Irizarry
Compass
| |
|
12/14/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$324,999
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
Socorro Fernandez
Exit Realty Achieve
| |
|
11/30/2022
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$140,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
$135,000
-3.57%
05/16/2023
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
11/09/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$325,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
Irene Guanill
Meet The Sellers
| |
|
10/03/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$170,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
-
| |
|
09/16/2022
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
615 ft²
|
$140,000
Studio
1 Bath
615 ft²
|
$135,000
-3.57%
07/07/2023
|
William Chester
Morris Park Realty Group
| |
|
08/18/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$185,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$173,000
-6.49%
07/18/2023
|
Joseph Cosentino
Westchester Realty Consultants
| |
|
08/10/2022
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$154,999
Studio
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Edward Meltser
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
06/27/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
700 ft²
|
$145,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
700 ft²
|
$140,000
-3.45%
03/30/2023
|
Allison Jaffe
Key Real Estate Services, LLC
| |
|
06/27/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$225,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
Christopher Rodriguez
Keller Williams Landmark II
| |
|
05/16/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$120,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Angelo Gonzalez
Realty By The Park
| |
|
05/09/2022
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$149,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Marc Windheuser
Keller Williams Rlty Landmark
| |
|
04/26/2022
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$334,999
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
-
-
|
Felisha Peralta
Keller Williams Realty NYC Grp
| |
|
04/21/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$165,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
-
-
|
Veronica Suarez
RE/MAX Distinguished Hms.&Prop
| |
|
03/24/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$167,999
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Maria K. Paleatsos
MP Power Realty Corp
| |
|
02/18/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$145,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Jose L. Reyes
Exit Realty Search
| |
|
02/02/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
800 ft²
|
$159,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
800 ft²
|
-
-
|
Gary Waller
Century 21 Metro Star
| |
|
01/28/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
780 ft²
|
$169,999
1 Bed
1 Bath
780 ft²
|
$170,000
+0.00%
08/04/2022
|
Jesica Lima
EXIT Realty Premier
| |
|
01/28/2022
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
755 ft²
|
$158,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
755 ft²
|
-
-
|
Vincent Buccieri
Today Realty Corp.
| |
|
05/06/2021
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
-
|
$329,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
|
$295,000
-10.33%
08/16/2022
|
Christopher Dobbs
Joyce Realty Corp
| |
|
03/03/2021
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$159,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$159,000
08/19/2021
|
Bonnie Stein
Julia B Fee Sothebys Int. Rlty
| |
|
01/18/2021
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
615 ft²
|
$135,000
Studio
1 Bath
615 ft²
|
$135,000
07/08/2021
|
Christina Narine
Ramon W. Pagan
| |
|
10/12/2020
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$139,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
$135,000
-2.88%
11/23/2020
|
Marc Windheuser
Keller Williams Rlty Landmark
| |
|
09/26/2020
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$139,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
-
-
|
Clara Zappetti
CLARA REALTY
| |
|
06/15/2020
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$120,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
$120,000
12/21/2020
|
Jesica Lima
EXIT Realty Premier
| |
|
10/29/2019
|
2 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
1000 ft²
|
$235,000
2 Bed
1 Bath
1000 ft²
|
$225,000
-4.26%
09/22/2021
|
Miguel Cabrera
Elliman
| |
|
09/08/2019
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$119,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
$119,000
01/14/2021
|
Mildred M. Valentin
Howard Hanna Rand Realty
| |
|
02/21/2019
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$119,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
$113,000
-5.04%
10/10/2019
|
Irene Guanill
Meet The Sellers
| |
|
01/09/2019
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$175,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$160,000
-8.57%
09/20/2019
|
Ryan C. Schwarz
Houlihan Lawrence Inc.
| |
|
01/08/2019
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
725 ft²
|
$142,500
1 Bed
1 Bath
725 ft²
|
$142,500
04/16/2019
|
Douglas J. Tricarico
Houlihan Lawrence Inc.
| |
|
12/10/2018
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$130,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$130,000
12/26/2019
|
Johan Gomez Tola
Keller Williams Realty Group
| |
|
10/02/2018
| |
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1175 ft²
|
$319,999
2 Bed
2 Bath
1175 ft²
|
$310,000
-3.12%
02/13/2019
|
Jessica Marte
Island Advantage Realty LLC
|
|
09/17/2018
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$134,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$130,000
-3.63%
01/24/2019
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
06/04/2018
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
600 ft²
|
$119,625
Studio
1 Bath
600 ft²
|
$111,000
-7.21%
02/15/2019
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
04/25/2018
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1200 ft²
|
$325,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1200 ft²
|
$325,000
01/30/2019
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
04/13/2018
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$124,900
1 Bed
1 Bath
|
$127,000
+1.68%
12/06/2018
|
Edisona Rexha
RE/MAX In the City
| |
|
04/02/2018
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1250 ft²
|
$355,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1250 ft²
|
$350,000
-1.41%
10/12/2018
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
03/21/2018
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$159,999
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$135,000
-15.62%
09/06/2018
|
Douglas J. Tricarico
Houlihan Lawrence Inc.
| |
|
01/15/2018
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
495 ft²
|
$90,000
Studio
1 Bath
495 ft²
|
$85,000
-5.56%
04/12/2018
|
Raysa Santos
RSM Real Estate Consultants
| |
|
01/12/2018
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1000 ft²
|
$239,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1000 ft²
|
$239,000
08/31/2018
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
12/13/2017
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
600 ft²
|
$119,000
Studio
1 Bath
600 ft²
|
$105,000
-11.76%
05/22/2018
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
11/20/2017
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$126,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$120,000
-4.76%
05/04/2018
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
10/26/2017
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
600 ft²
|
$99,000
Studio
1 Bath
600 ft²
|
$100,000
+1.01%
08/20/2018
|
Maria Rosa
Century 21 Metro Star
| |
|
05/15/2017
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
600 ft²
|
$99,999
Studio
1 Bath
600 ft²
|
$92,000
-8.00%
11/21/2017
|
Maria Rosa
Century 21 Metro Star
| |
|
02/11/2017
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$137,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$125,000
-8.76%
09/29/2017
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
11/07/2016
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
600 ft²
|
$98,000
Studio
1 Bath
600 ft²
|
$84,500
-13.78%
08/22/2017
|
Maria Rosa
Century 21 Metro Star
| |
|
10/25/2016
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
750 ft²
|
$109,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
750 ft²
|
$98,000
-10.09%
02/07/2017
|
Gregory Kafcos
Century 21 Kafcos Realty
| |
|
09/09/2016
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
700 ft²
|
$111,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
700 ft²
|
$103,000
-7.21%
06/06/2017
|
Maria Rosa
Century 21 Metro Star
| |
|
06/03/2016
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
800 ft²
|
$122,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
800 ft²
|
$117,000
-4.10%
04/18/2017
|
Pamela Busgith
Century 21 Metro Star
| |
|
04/29/2016
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
700 ft²
|
$109,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
700 ft²
|
$102,500
-5.96%
09/19/2017
|
Maria Rosa
Century 21 Metro Star
| |
|
09/15/2014
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
-
|
$63,000
Studio
1 Bath
|
$63,000
03/17/2016
|
Roman Davydov
Exit Realty First Choice
| |
|
07/12/2013
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1250 ft²
|
$249,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1250 ft²
|
$210,000
-15.66%
12/20/2013
|
Steven Librett
Librett Real Estate Group Inc
| |
|
06/23/2013
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
800 ft²
|
$85,000
Studio
1 Bath
800 ft²
|
$81,000
-4.71%
10/17/2013
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
03/15/2013
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
800 ft²
|
$135,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
800 ft²
|
$90,000
-33.33%
07/26/2013
|
Irene G. Guanill
De Luca Realty Group INC
| |
|
09/25/2012
|
2 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1147 ft²
|
$229,000
2 Bed
2 Bath
1147 ft²
|
$200,000
-12.66%
06/20/2013
|
Ariel Pena
RE/MAX Voyage Realty
| |
|
08/06/2012
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
800 ft²
|
$112,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
800 ft²
|
$100,000
-10.71%
12/21/2012
|
Jose L. Reyes
Exit Realty Search
| |
|
05/18/2012
|
1 Bed
|
1 Bath
|
800 ft²
|
$129,000
1 Bed
1 Bath
800 ft²
|
$122,000
-5.43%
02/22/2013
|
Urmilla Busgith
Metro Star Realty LLC
| |
|
04/18/2012
|
3 Bed
|
2 Bath
|
1250 ft²
|
$299,000
3 Bed
2 Bath
1250 ft²
|
$270,000
-9.70%
08/24/2012
|
Steven Librett
Librett Real Estate Group Inc
| |
|
03/01/2012
|
Studio
|
1 Bath
|
500 ft²
|
$75,000
Studio
1 Bath
500 ft²
|
$68,000
-9.33%
10/19/2012
|
Mildred M. Valentin
Howard Hanna Rand Realty
|
Building Info
- 157 Units
- 3 Units for Sale
Phone: 425-283-2930
Address: 335 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10017