by RH Advisors

See Home Value
$380,000
● House - Off Market

372 Main St

Brookhaven, NY 11733
bedrooms
5 Beds
bathrooms
2 Baths, 1 Half Bath
square feet
2,543 Ft²
$2,671
Est. Monthly

About This Property

Situated in one of Suffolk County's most coveted and prestigious communities, this rare opportunity offers unmatched value and potential on a sprawling .74-acre lot perched high on a scenic hill. As the lowest-priced property on the market in the entire area, this approximately 2,500 sq ft colonial with a detached 2-car garage is ideal for investors, builders, or buyers looking to fully renovate or reimagine a home from the ground up. The setting provides exceptional privacy, an elevated vantage point, and the chance to create a true private oasis on an oversized parcel-an offering that is nearly impossible to find at this price point. The home requires a full renovation throughout, but the footprint, location, and land make it an extraordinary canvas for your dream project, whether you plan to modernize the existing structure or design something entirely new. Enjoy a massive driveway with ample off-street parking, plus unbeatable proximity to Stony Brook and Port Jefferson Villages, top-rated Three Village Schools, restaurants, marinas, North Shore beaches, yacht clubs, and everyday conveniences. Homes and lots like this rarely come to market-bring your contractor, bring your vision, and transform this property into the beauty it deserves to be. Being sold strictly as-is
Unit Size
2,543 Ft²
Days on Market
90 days
Land Size
0.74 acres
Price per sqft
$157
Property Type
House
Property Taxes
$707
HOA Dues
-
Year Built
1850

Payment Calculator

Cap Rate Calculator

Last updated: 7 months ago (OneKey MLS #KEY940704)

Price History

Date / Event Date Event Price
Mar 2, 2026 Sold
Sold
Dec 24, 2025 In contract -
In contract
Dec 2, 2025 Listed by Frontline Realty Group LLC $399,900
Listed by Frontline Realty Group LLC
Apr 20, 2015 Sold
Sold

Property Highlights

Garage

Building Info

Overview

    General

  • Year Built: 1850
  • Effective Year Built: 1850
  • Total Rooms: 12
  • Bedroom Count: 5
  • Bathroom Count: 3
  • Full Bathrooms: 3
  • Partial Bathrooms: 3
  • Building Condition: 0
  • Building Quality: 0
  • Construction Type: 0
  • Building Style: 0
  • Exterior Walls Type: 19
  • Interior Walls Type: 0
  • Roof Shape Type: 0
  • Roof Cover Type: 0
  • Floor Count: 250
  • Floor Cover: 0
  • Basement Type: 9
  • Basement Area: 0
  • Garage Type: 0
  • Parking Space Count: 0
  • Patio Type: 0
  • Porch Type: 0
  • Pool Type: 0

    Dimensions

  • Lot Size Square Feet: 32,234
  • Total Building Area: 2,543
  • Building Area: 2,543
  • Building Area Measurement: L

    Heating and Cooling

  • Fireplace Count: 1
  • Air Conditioning: 0
  • Heating: 13
  • Heated Square Feet: 2,543
  • Heating Fuel Type: 0

    Utilities

  • Sewer System: 0
  • Water Service: 0

Building

  • Building Type: 0
  • Property Class: R
  • Subdivision: SETAUKET
  • Land Acres: 0000000740
  • Standard Land Use Code: 1001
  • County Land Use Code: 210
  • Legal Description 1: N ROUTE 25A & ANO E J HIGGINS S#2-54 S WAINSCOTT WOODS W MUSSON & ANO

Neighborhood

  • School District Name: Three Village Central School District
  • School Tax School District: THREE VILLAGE
  • Census Tract: 159700

Geography

  • Assessors Map Reference: MAP 8600000
  • Account Number: 00008610942
  • District: 0200-0
  • Section: 90.00
  • Parcel: 0200-090.00-02.00-008.004
  • Block: 2
  • Lot: 8.004
  • Municipality: BROOKHAVEN
  • Latitude: 40.9454
  • Longitude: -73.0921

    Address

  • Full Address: 372 Main St
  • Address - House Number: 372
  • Address - Street Name: Main
  • Address - Suffix Type: St
  • State: NY
  • City Name: Setauket
  • Carrier Code: C013
  • 4-Digit Zip Code: 3842
  • Zip Code: 11733

Valuation

    Tax

  • Tax Year: 2022
  • Tax Amount: $0
  • Initial Tax Delinquent Year: 2020
  • Tax Rate Code Area: 472201

    Appraisal Valuation

  • Standard Deviation: 0.2314
  • Valuation Date: Feb 14, 2024
  • Confidence Score: 53
  • Final Value: 483,996
  • High Value: 596,024
  • Low Value: 371,967

    Market Valuation

  • Market Total Value: $3,148
  • Market Land Value: $926
  • Market Improvement Value: $2,222

    Assessments Valuation

  • Assessed Year: 2023
  • Assessed Total Value: $1,700
  • Assessed Land Value: $500
  • Assessed Improvements Value: $1,200

    Sales

  • Current Sale Contract Date: Mar 26, 2015
  • Current Sale Recording Date: Apr 20, 2015
  • Current Sale Price:
  • Current Sale Document Type: O
  • Previous Sale Recording Date: Apr 15, 2015
  • Previous Sale Contract Date: Nov 14, 2013
  • Previous Sale Amount: $190,646
  • Previous Sale Document Type: 12
Data used for valuation calculations is provided by RealtyHop, and other third party sources

Comparables

Unit
Status
Type
Beds
Baths
ft²
Price/ft²
Asking Price
Listed On
Closing Price
Sold On
HOA + Taxes

About Setauket-East Setauket


Similar Homes for Sale

Currently no similar homes around

Nearby Rentals

Unit for rent at 18 Walnut Avenue, Setauket, NY, 11733

$5,200 /mo

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 2,250 ft²
18 Walnut Avenue, Setauket, NY, 11733 Listing by Edward Schmidt
Unit for rent at 27 Walnut Avenue, Poquott, NY, 11733

$3,000 /mo

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 800 ft²
27 Walnut Avenue #2, Poquott, NY, 11733 Listing by Shaughnessy Dusling
Unit for rent at 126 E Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY, 11777

$2,700 /mo

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 633 ft²
126 E Main Street #B, Port Jefferson, NY, 11777 Listing by Michael A. Omedes


Frequently Asked Questions

When was property at 372 Main Street built and last sold?
The property at 372 Main Street was built in 1850 and last sold on Mar 26, 2015 for $55,091.
How much is this home worth?
The estimated value of the home located at 372 Main Street is $0.
What are some comparable homes to 372 Main Street?
There are currently no comparable homes to 372 Main Street.