by RH Advisors

See Home Value
$4,925,000
Condo - Off Market

205 E 16TH Street #5A

Manhattan, NY 10003
bedrooms
5 Beds
bathrooms
5 Baths, 1 Half Bath
square feet
3602 Sqft
$7,363,843
RealtyHop Estimate
49.52%
Since Feb 1, 2018
NY-New York
Primary Model

About This Property

Residence 5A at The Abbey Condominium, located at 205 East 16th Street between Third Avenue and Rutherford Place, is a distinctive, exceptional offering in a striking, historic landmark. Constructed in 1888, the Romanesque Revival-style building originally functioned as a parish house for St. George's Church next door. While the historical character and integrity of the building is maintained throughout, the home has been thoroughly modernized and updated through a thoughtful, meticulous renovation.

A proper foyer and adjacent extra-large mud room/walk-in coat closet set the tone for the size and scope of this spacious home. An expansive great room, with dramatic ceiling heights of 11'9", sits at the center of the residence and is the ideal entertaining space. This spectacular dining/living area features the original coffered ceilings and stained glass windows, highlighting bright, southern exposures. Tucked to the side, the open, eat-in kitchen boasts custom oak cabinetry, a mosaic tile backsplash, hammered stone countertops, terra cotta tiled floors, stainless steel appliances and a Shaws original farmhouse sink. A roomy walk-in pantry offers additional kitchen storage space.

The entrance to the grand master suite opens to a spacious, windowed home office with large built-in desk. Stairs lead down to the private, airy master bedroom with soaring 10'9" ceilings and a lovely, sunny solarium and terrace. The master bathroom, clad in elaborate mosaic tile, showcases original, exposed brownstone columns.

The main level features three additional bedrooms, one of which is located off the living room and could also function as a den. The oversized, corner bedroom offers both southern and eastern exposures over St. George's Church, and has a deep closet and en-suite bathroom. Also on this floor is a suburban-sized laundry room/service entrance, which includes two full-sized washers and dryers, and ample shelving and hanging space. On the upper level, the fifth bedroom is a secluded retreat, with more breathtaking stained glass windows (and views), a walk-in closet and an en-suite marble bathroom. All of the unique 4.5 bathrooms are appointed with high-end fixtures and TOTO Washlet toilets.

Antique stained glass and exquisite vintage light fixtures are found throughout this extraordinary home. Other features include oak hardwood flooring and central HVAC throughout.

The Abbey is situated on a quiet, tree-lined block with no through traffic, in the charming Stuyvesant Square Historic District. The full-service condo's staff consists of a 24/7 doorman, porter and live-in super. The building is just a half block from the historic four-acre Stuyvesant Square Park, which boasts magnificent old trees and plantings, a dog park, beautiful fountains, bluestone sidewalks and the original cast iron fence from 1847.  The Abbey is also in close proximity to both Gramercy Park and Union Square, thereby providing several top-rated dining, shopping and entertainment options and is extremely accessible to several subway and bus lines.
Unit Size
3,602Ft²
Days on Market
122 days
Land Size
-
Price per sqft
$1,367
Property Type
Condo
Property Taxes
$4,407
HOA Dues
$3,284
Year Built
1888
Last updated: 3 months ago (RLS #PRCH-221829)

Price History

Date / Event Date Event Price
Jan 12, 2018 Sold to Beth Anderson-song $4,925,000
Sold to Beth Anderson-song
Sep 12, 2017 Listed by Compass $5,250,000
Listed by Compass
Oct 13, 2010 Sold to Laurel Rubin $5,283,180
Sold to Laurel Rubin

Property Highlights

Doorman
Elevator
Garage
Interior Details

Bedroom Information

Bedrooms: 5

Bathroom Information

Full Bathrooms: 4
Half Bathrooms: 1

Interior Information

Appliances: Dryer, Washer Dryer Allowed, Washer
Living Area: 3602

Room Information

Rooms: 9
Exterior Details

Property Information

Year Built: 1888

Building Information

Outdoor Living Structures: Building Terrace, Terrace
Pets Allowed: Building Yes, Yes

Lot Information

Lot Size Dimensions: 86.5 x 115.0


Comparables

Unit
Status
Type
Beds
Baths
ft²
Price/ft²
Asking Price
Listed On
Closing Price
Sold On
HOA + Taxes
Co-op
5 Beds
5 Baths
3,300 ft²
$1,367/ft²
$4,510,000 Mar 4, 2022
$4,510,000 Jun 27, 2022
$6,384/mo
Co-op
4 Beds
4 Baths
3,200 ft²
$1,428/ft²
$4,568,000 Apr 4, 2022
$4,568,000 Mar 3, 2023
$6,188/mo
Condo
4 Beds
4 Baths
3,200 ft²
$1,406/ft²
$4,500,000 Aug 4, 2020
$4,500,000 Oct 16, 2020
$7,264/mo
Condo
4 Beds
5 Baths
2,552 ft²
$1,957/ft²
$4,995,000 Apr 28, 2021
$4,995,000 Aug 5, 2021
$7,883/mo
Condo
4 Beds
4 Baths
2,696 ft²
$2,151/ft²
$5,800,000 Sep 6, 2022
$5,800,000 Oct 29, 2022
$7,626/mo
Condo
4 Beds
5 Baths
2,539 ft²
$2,294/ft²
$5,825,000 Oct 19, 2021
$5,825,000 Apr 21, 2022
$7,371/mo
Condo
4 Beds
3 Baths
4,200 ft²
$1,250/ft²
$5,250,000 Mar 28, 2023
-
$5,252/mo
Condo
5 Beds
4 Baths
-
$4,995,000 Sep 14, 2023
-
$5,752/mo
House
6 Beds
6 Baths
4,917 ft²
$1,139/ft²
$5,600,000 Dec 8, 2021
-
-
Co-op
3 Beds
3 Baths
3,280 ft²
$1,675/ft²
$5,495,000 Feb 1, 2023
-
$6,345/mo
Co-op
3 Beds
3 Baths
2,729 ft²
$1,832/ft²
$5,000,000 May 20, 2022
-
$14,625/mo
Condo
3 Beds
4 Baths
2,510 ft²
$2,114/ft²
$5,305,000 May 10, 2022
-
$6,310/mo

Past Sales

Date Unit Beds Baths Sqft Price Closed Owner Listed By
20230822 Unit 2D
08/22/2023
2D
3 Bed
3 Bath
2111 ft²
$2,100,000
bedrooms
3 Bed
bathrooms
3 Bath
square feet
2111 ft²
$1,900,000 -9.52%
04/11/2024
-
Ivana Tagliamonte
Compass
20220615 Unit 4B
06/15/2022
4B
1 Bed
2 Bath
1305 ft²
$2,150,000
bedrooms
1 Bed
bathrooms
2 Bath
square feet
1305 ft²
-
09/22/2022
Paige Neuhauser
Compass
20210503 Unit 5P
05/03/2021
5P
2 Bed
3 Bath
2025 ft²
$3,250,000
bedrooms
2 Bed
bathrooms
3 Bath
square feet
2025 ft²
$2,850,000 -12.31%
08/11/2021
Mary Wyatt
Corcoran Group
20210205 Unit 4E
02/05/2021
4E
1 Bed
2 Bath
911 ft²
$1,300,000
bedrooms
1 Bed
bathrooms
2 Bath
square feet
911 ft²
$1,355,000 +4.23%
04/01/2021
Rocchio Engelbrechtsen
Compass
20200917 Unit 3E
09/17/2020
3E
1 Bed
1 Bath
988 ft²
$1,250,000
bedrooms
1 Bed
bathrooms
1 Bath
square feet
988 ft²
$1,200,000 -4.00%
12/30/2020
Keren Atzlan
Reserve Partners
20170912 Unit 5A
09/12/2017
5A
5 Bed
5 Bath
3602 ft²
$5,250,000
bedrooms
5 Bed
bathrooms
5 Bath
square feet
3602 ft²
$4,925,000 -6.19%
01/12/2018
-
Henry Hershkowitz
Related Sales, LLC
20161130 Unit 2D
11/30/2016
2D
3 Bed
2.5 Bath
2111 ft²
$2,300,000
bedrooms
3 Bed
bathrooms
2.5 Bath
square feet
2111 ft²
-
-
-
Kyle Haas
Compass
20161027 Unit 5AB
10/27/2016
5AB
5 Bed
4.5 Bath
3462 ft²
-
bedrooms
5 Bed
bathrooms
4.5 Bath
square feet
3462 ft²
-
-
-
David Margolies
Compass
20160518 Unit 2D
05/18/2016
2D
3 Bed
2.5 Bath
2111 ft²
$2,995,000
bedrooms
3 Bed
bathrooms
2.5 Bath
square feet
2111 ft²
-
-
-
Sofia Dmitriyeva
R New York
20150402 Unit 6B
04/02/2015
6B
2 Bed
2 Bath
1200 ft²
$1,799,000
bedrooms
2 Bed
bathrooms
2 Bath
square feet
1200 ft²
$1,730,750 -3.79%
09/09/2015
Paul D. Zweben
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
20140528 Unit 4F
05/28/2014
4F
2 Bed
2 Bath
1120 ft²
$1,575,000
bedrooms
2 Bed
bathrooms
2 Bath
square feet
1120 ft²
$1,710,000 +8.57%
09/04/2014
Philip Horigan
The Corcoran Group
20140421 Unit 3B
04/21/2014
3B
1 Bed
1.5 Bath
1322 ft²
$1,995,000
bedrooms
1 Bed
bathrooms
1.5 Bath
square feet
1322 ft²
-
-
-
Kathi Jacob
Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
20130924 Unit 4D
09/24/2013
4D
3 Bed
3 Bath
2195 ft²
$2,975,000
bedrooms
3 Bed
bathrooms
3 Bath
square feet
2195 ft²
-
-
-
Kathi Jacob
Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
20130819 Unit 1D
08/19/2013
1D
4 Bed
3 Bath
2536 ft²
$2,995,000
bedrooms
4 Bed
bathrooms
3 Bath
square feet
2536 ft²
-
-
-
Kathi Jacob
Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
20130801 Unit 5P
08/01/2013
5P
2 Bed
2.5 Bath
2026 ft²
$2,650,000
bedrooms
2 Bed
bathrooms
2.5 Bath
square feet
2026 ft²
-
07/21/2014
Kathi Jacob
Halstead dba Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
20130712 Unit 2D
07/12/2013
2D
3 Bed
2.5 Bath
2111 ft²
$2,849,000
bedrooms
3 Bed
bathrooms
2.5 Bath
square feet
2111 ft²
-
05/22/2014
Kathi Jacob
Halstead dba Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
20121215 Unit 6B
12/15/2012
6B
2 Bed
2 Bath
1200 ft²
$1,750,000
bedrooms
2 Bed
bathrooms
2 Bath
square feet
1200 ft²
-
-
-
Paul Zweben
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
20050922 Unit 3E
09/22/2005
3E
1 Bed
1 Bath
988 ft²
$968,240
bedrooms
1 Bed
bathrooms
1 Bath
square feet
988 ft²
$926,608 -4.30%
06/12/2006
Deanna Kory
The Corcoran Group

Building Info

The Abbey 205 East 16th Street, New York, NY 10003
  • 36 Units
  • 1 Unit for Sale
More about this Building
205 East 16th Street
Want to find out who owns 205 East 16th Street, New York, NY 10003? Get detailed property transactions here .

About Midtown Manhattan


Similar Homes for Sale

Unit for sale at 50 Gramercy Park North, Manhattan, NY 10010

$5,000,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 2,729 ft²
50 Gramercy Park North #3B, Manhattan, NY 10010 Listing by Paige Neuhauser
Unit for sale at 40 East 19th Street, Manhattan, NY 10003

$5,495,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3,280 ft²
40 East 19th Street #5, Manhattan, NY 10003 Listing by Jeremy Stein
Unit for sale at 111 East 19th Street, Manhattan, NY 10003

$5,600,000

  • 6 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • 4,917 ft²
111 East 19th Street #HOUSE, Manhattan, NY 10003 Listing by Leslie Lalehzar

Nearby Rentals

Unit for rent at 280 West 24th Street, New York, NY, 10011

$4,477 /mo

  • Studio
  • 1 Bath
280 West 24th Street #6N, New York, NY, 10011 Listing by Gal Yehzkel
Unit for rent at 325 Kent Avenue, BROOKLYN, NY, 11249

$4,421 /mo

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
325 Kent Avenue #S707, BROOKLYN, NY, 11249 Listing by Andrea Cortese
Unit for rent at 207 West 11th Street, New York, NY 10014

$4,500 /mo

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 440 ft²
207 West 11th Street #1D, New York, NY 10014 Listing by Luis A. Juarez


Quantcast