223 Mac Donough St
Brooklyn, NY 11233

Building Sale in Bedford-Stuyvesant / New York / NY / 11233


20% Min Down
Building Sale
Listed Oct 23rd, 2020, Built in 1899
Send Message
Common Charges
No Data
Property Taxes
No Data
Total Monthly Payment
Est. Rental Income
Cap Rate
No Data
HopScore Analysis
HopScore Market Price:
Difference from Asking Price:
Closest Comparable:
None Found
Nestled in the Landmark Stuyvesant Heights Historic District, 223 MacDonough Street is a grand legal 2-family townhouse that has been well maintained over the years. This extra-large 4-story home built in 1872 includes a rare 3-story extension added in 1918 creating about 4,000 sf of living space! The garden floor, parlor floor and third floor come with a 12 x 15 sf extension adding an additional spacious bedroom on each of these floors. This property is currently set up as a 3-family with an upper duplex and 2 separate apartments on the parlor floor and garden floor. This residence retains some original details such as original plaster work, doors and windows moldings and five decorative fireplaces, and all 3 kitchens and 4 bathrooms in this residence have been recently updated. The upper duplex is gorgeous, bright and extra spacious. The third floor is an open space with kitchen, dining, living room with an office space and a full bathroom. There is also a large bedroom with 3 windows in the extension that is currently used as a painting studio and 2 more large bedrooms on the fourth floor with an office or a den and another full bathroom. The parlor floor is extra special with high ceilings and oversized South facing windows overlooking this beautiful prime block. The parlor floor is completely open creating a loft like feeling. The kitchen is open and there is a large windowed bathroom on that floor. The spacious bedroom in the extension comes also with 3 windows facing the quiet garden. The garden level apartment is in great condition. Here again, the kitchen is open on the dining room/living room with a large bedroom in the front of the apartment facing the street and another large bedroom in the extension of the building facing the lush, quiet, designed garden paved with bluestone. With 3 kitchens and 4 full bathrooms on each floor, you could easily transform this property into an upper triplex + a garden rental apartment or into 2 separate duplexes. Any combination is possible and very easy to do. This unique brownstone is around the corner from one of the grandest churches in all of Stuyvesant Heights: Our Lady of Victory, on a landmarked brownstone block. Conveniently close to the A and C subway stations as well as many of Bedford Stuyvesant's most reputable hot spots: Saraghina, Lunatico, Peaches, L'Antagoniste among others. This house is not to be missed and a unique offering for the most discerning buyer who wants to be able to move right in as well as to collect some substantial income from the rental apartment(s) without doing too much work. 223 MacDonough Street is part of a long row of fourteen houses built in the classic Italianate style. It is notable as one of the two earliest rows in the Stuyvesant Historic District. For over 50 years this building, along with 221 MacDonough Street, were the home of the Bedford Institute. All mechanicals are in a good and working condition. This property is sold as is and is shown by appointment only. Feel free to email me directly if you have any further questions.
Features & Amenities
Dogs Allowed
Cats Allowed
Listed By
Patricia Laligant
(917) 362-7749
Price History
Date Event Price Source
2021-02-09 Price Drop $2,650,000 Compass
2020-10-23 Listed $2,890,000 Compass
2017-11-29 Listed $0 Halstead Property, Llc
Want to find out who owns 223 Mac Donough St? Get detailed property transactions, assessments, mortgage info.
On the Map
Nearby Public Transportation
0.24 mi at Kingston-Throop (Fulton St and Throop Ave)
0.90 mi at Kingston Av (Eastern Pkwy and Kingston Ave)
0.90 mi at Kosciusko St (Broadway and Patchen Ave)
0.93 mi at Utica Av (Eastern Pkwy and Utica Ave)
0.95 mi at Gates Av (Broadway and Linden St)
Recent Transactions at 223 Mac Donough St
Unit Br Ba Sqft Time Listed Listing $ Listed By Closed Closing $ Diff Buyer(s)
Unit Stu 0 Bath - 165 Days 2017-11-29
Jevon Gratineau
Halstead Property, LLC
$2,050,000 Jevon Gratineau
Halstead Property, LLC
$1,800,000 -$250,000
Wama1 Llc
Unit - - - - -
- - 1980-08-04
$0 - Williams Lucille
Unit - - - - -
- - 1980-07-15
$0 - Davis Leonie
Unit - - - - -
- - 1979-08-15
$0 - Sec Of Housing Urban Development
Unit - - - - -
- - 1968-06-27
$0 - Olano Rafael
Unit - - - - -
- - 1968-03-11
$0 - Kewbrook Realty Inc
View All Transactions at 223 Mac Donough St

Nearby Schools

(within attendance boundary)
500 Macon St, Brooklyn, NY 11233
Public  •  Elementary  •  Grades PK to 5
New York City Geographic District #16
MS 35 STEPHEN DECATUR  •  0.09 mi
272 Mcdonough St, Brooklyn, NY 11233
Public  •  Middle School  •  Grades 6 to 8
New York City Geographic District #16
1700 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11213
Public  •  High School  •  Grades 9 to 12
New York City Geographic District #16
School zoning information and other data are provided by RealtyHop Schools and 3rd party sources. The contents of the database are not guaranteed to be accurate or timely. Contact the schools or districts before making any decisions using on this data.
Room By Room Floorplans and Photos
The apartment appears to have the following available photos. Note that all categories are based on data provided by the agent or firm advertising the sale, our internal listings quality team, and our HopScore machine vision algorithms. In total, the listing has 2 photos or floorplans, and we present a breakdown of each photo with the associated room or features.
Comparable Apartments for Rent
1 day ago
1511 Bedford Avenue
Crown Heights, Central Brooklyn, Brooklyn
$1,715 Studio 1 Bath
By Kim Cheslow
5 days ago
175 Stockholm Street
Bushwick, Northern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
$2,000 Studio 1 Bath
By Jessica Fonseca
6 days ago
539 Gates Avenue
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Northern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
$2,000 1 Bed 1 Bath
By Therese Russo
10 hours ago
959 Carroll Street
Crown Heights, Central Brooklyn, Brooklyn
$1,900 1 Bed 1 Bath
By Zack Niasoff
13 hours ago
172 Jefferson Street
Bushwick, Northern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
$1,900 1 Bed 1 Bath
By Bryan Soto
4 days ago
509 Saratoga Avenue
Brownsville, Eastern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
$1,895 1 Bed 1 Bath
By Steven BenShabat
4 days ago
350 Greene Avenue
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Northern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
$1,800 Studio 1 Bath
By Charlie Lopez
Similar Buildings