Overview

1136 5th Avenue

1136 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10128

Co-op in Carnegie Hill

46 Units

1136 Fifth Avenue was built in 1925 and designed by George F. Pelham.

Today, it’s a full-service building that rises 14 stories and spans 43 units. It offers sprawling pre-war homes that may include private elevator landings, versatile layouts, nine foot ceilings, oversized windows, herringbone wood floors, crown moldings, elegant foyers and wood-burning fireplaces.

Extras include a live-in super and private storage facilities.

Residents also benefit from being based in the Carnegie Hill neighborhood across from Central Park and just steps from the Jackie Kennedy Onassis Reservoir,

Nearby MTA options include the Q, B and C trains as well as the 4/5/6 subway lines.

Ebenezer Wesleyan Garden, Cherry Tree Park, Mae Grant Playground and Ruppert Park are also nearby.


See the full transaction history for 1136 5th Avenue below.

Currently For Sale

2 Bed at 120 Riverside Blvd Unit 1MD $1,650,000 1136 5th Ave Unit 1MD

2 Bed | 2 Bath

Listed by Howard Margolis
2 Bed at 120 Riverside Blvd Unit 1D $1,650,000 1136 5th Ave Unit 1D

2 Bed | 2 Bath

Listed by Corinne Pulitzer

Building Experts

Mary Rutherfurd Brown Harris Stevens 1 closed deals in this building

Building Info

Amenities

  • Laundry in Unit
  • Laundry in Building
  • Dogs Allowed
  • Cats Allowed
  • Doorman
  • Through-wall Air Conditioning
  • New Construction
  • Elevator
  • Number of Elevators: 2



Building Policies

  • Cats Allowed
  • Dogs Allowed

Overview

  • Basement Type

    2
  • Gross Building Area

    122,701
  • Lot Size Depth Feet

    102
  • Lot Size Frontage Feet

    101
  • Year Built

    1925

General

  • First Altered Year

  • Recent Altered Year

  • Building Count

    1
  • Floor Count

    14
  • Total Unit Count

    46
  • Building Frontage

    96
  • Building Depth

    91
  • Lot Area Sqft

    10,361

Unit Count

  • Residential Unit Count

    43

Building Floor Area

  • Residential Building Floor Area

    121,401
  • Commercial Building Floor Area

    1,300
  • Office Building Floor Area

    1
  • Garage Building Floor Area

  • Factory Building Floor Area

  • Retail Building Floor Area

  • Storage Building Floor Area

  • Other Building Floor Area


Floor Area Ratios

  • Built Floor Area Ratio

    11.84
  • Residential Floor Area Ratio

    10.00
  • Commercial Floor Area Ratio

    0.00
  • Facilities Floor Area Ratio

    10.00

Building

  • Building Type

    D4
  • Lot Type

    3
  • Irregular Lot Code

    N
  • Land Use

    03
  • Proximity Code

    2
  • Extension Code

  • Easements


Ownership

  • Current Owner's Full Name

    1136 TENANTS CORP

Neighborhood

  • School District

    02
  • Community District

    108
  • City Council District

    4
  • Historic District Name

    Expanded Carnegie Hill Historic District
  • Landmark Name

  • Police Precinct

    19
  • Fire Company

    E053
  • Health Area

    2820
  • Health Center District

  • Sanitation District

  • Sanitation District Borough

    1
  • Sanitation Subsection

    5A

Zoning

  • Limited Height District

  • Zoning

    R10
  • Special Purpose District 1

    PI
  • Special Purpose District 2

  • Special Purpose District 3

  • Split Boundary Zone Indicator

    N
  • Zoning Commercial Overlay 1

  • Zoning Commercial Overlay 2

  • Zoning District 2

  • Zoning District 3

  • Zoning District 4


Geography

  • Full Street Address

    1136 5 AVENUE
  • Zip Code

    10128
  • Borough Name

    MN
  • Borough Code

    1
  • Block

    1506
  • Lot

    69
  • Borough Block Lot

    1015060069
  • Condominium Number


Valuation

  • Assessed Land Value

    $2,232,000
  • Assessed Total Value

    $12,652,650
  • Exempt Land Value

    $85,320
  • Exempt Total Value

    $85,320



Neighborhood

Stats & Trends

$6,375,000

Median Asking

4.13%

Below Asking

$2,461

Sale Price/ft²

168

Days on Market

Transportation

6

at 96th St 0.28 mi | 7 min walk

4

5

6

at 86th St 0.53 mi | 13 min walk

C

B

at 103rd St 0.68 mi | 17 min walk

2

3

at 110th St-Central Park North 0.86 mi | 21 min walk

Schools

School Type Grades Distance
Ps 198 Isador E Ida Straus Elementary PK to 5 0.37 mi
Jhs 167 Robert F Wagner Middle School 6 to 8 1.05 mi
Life Sciences Secondary School High School 9 to 12 0.6 mi
Eagle Academy for Young Men of Harlem Secondary School 6 to 11 2.14 mi
New Explorations into Sciencetech and Math High School Other KG to 12 4.85 mi
Urban Assembly School for Applied Math and Science (the) High School 6 to 12 4.6 mi
Thurgood Marshall Academy Lower School Elementary KG to 5 2.85 mi
Hamilton Heights School Elementary KG to 5 2.75 mi
River East Elementary Elementary PK to 5 1.46 mi
Anderson School (the) Elementary KG to 8 1.21 mi
Tag Young Scholars Elementary KG to 8 0.86 mi
Bilingual Bicultural School (the) Elementary PK to 5 0.85 mi
Central Park East I Elementary PK to 5 0.6 mi
Vanguard High School High School 9 to 12 1.52 mi
School zoning information and other data are provided by RealtyHop Schools and 3rd party sources. The contents of the database are not guaranteed to be accurate or timely. Contact the schools or districts before making any decisions using on this data.

Recent Updates

Sep 23, 2021

Unit 1MD - 2 Bed | 2 Bath

$1,650,000

Price Drop -$200,000 (-10.8%)

Sep 23, 2021

Unit 1D - 2 Bed | 2 Bath

$1,650,000

Price Drop -$200,000 (-10.8%)

Sep 10, 2021

Unit 1MD - 2 Bed | 2 Bath

Status Change

Sep 10, 2021

Unit 1D - 2 Bed | 2 Bath

Status Change

Aug 20, 2021

Unit 5C - 2 Bed | 2.5 Bath

Contract Pending

Status Change

Inquire about this Building

Contact A Local Real Estate Expert

(646) 760-8420

By proceeding, you consent to receive calls, texts and voicemails at the number you provided (may be recorded and may be autodialed and use pre-recorded and artificial voices), and email, from RealtyHop, Opcity, realtor.com and their network of service providers about your inquiry and other home-related matters. More

Units

Transaction history for 1136 5th Avenue

Unit Br Ba ft² Listed Listing Agent Asking
Common Charges
Closed Closing Buyer(s)
Unit 1MD 2 2 0 Aug 17, 2021 Howard Margolis $1,650,000
$5,535/mo
Active
Unit 1D 2 2 0 Jul 16, 2021 Corinne Pulitzer $1,650,000
$5,535/mo
Active
Unit 11B - - - - - - Jul 28, 2021 $3,185,000 Elizabeth Fuerstman
Daniel Weiner
Unit 2A - - - - - - Dec 6, 2018 $4,350,000 Co-trustee Douglas Kanter
Irrev Trust For The Benefit Of Samantha Alex Fuld
Co-trustee Lori Susan Kanter-tritsch
Unit 10A 3 3 - Apr 25, 2018 Leslie R. Coleman
Brown Harris Stevens
$4,950,000
$7,141/mo
Oct 4, 2018
161 Days
$4,775,000
-3.54%
Natalie Cass Stange
Tjark Eiko Stange
Unit 5A 3 2.5 - Mar 9, 2018 Daniela Kunen
Elliman
$6,850,000
$6,013/mo
Sep 24, 2018
198 Days
$6,350,000
-7.30%
Michael H Siegel
Susan J Siegel
Unit 7B 3 2 2,580 Dec 13, 2016 Karen Kelley
The Corcoran Group
$6,350,000
$5,219/mo
May 10, 2017
147 Days
$6,050,000
-4.72%
Lori E Bernstein
William S Bernstein
Unit 12A 3 2.5 - Sep 30, 2016 Mary Rutherfurd
Brown Harris Stevens
$6,995,000
$7,306/mo
Jan 10, 2017
101 Days
$6,500,000
-7.08%
Diana L Beattie
Richard I Beattie
Unit 14A - - - - - - Apr 7, 2016 $5,950,000 Jonathan M Moses
Abigail Young
Unit 3A 3 3 - Sep 16, 2015 Gregory M. Roache
Brown Harris Stevens
$6,400,000
$4,638/mo
Mar 10, 2016
175 Days
$6,400,000 William S White
Unit 9A 3 3 - Nov 18, 2014 Carrie Chiang
The Corcoran Group
$5,950,000
$5,737/mo
Sep 21, 2015
306 Days
$5,950,000 Betsy F Ross
Unit PH14C - - - - - - Aug 18, 2014 $35,000,000 Abigail Levy
Anton Levy
Unit 1E - - - - - - May 13, 2014 $710,000 Ruth Anne Giannetto
Unit 3B 3 3 - Sep 5, 2013 Stephanie Kanner
Fox Residential Group, Inc.
$4,100,000
$3,528/mo
Feb 27, 2014
174 Days
$4,100,000 Joel C Coleman
Lois M Coleman
Unit 8C - - - - - - Dec 26, 2012 - Michael Calabrese Fifth Avenue Residence Trust
Unit 9A - - - - - - Jul 28, 2011 $7,000,000 Erika M Millet
Timothy K Millet
Unit 3A - - - - - - Jan 25, 2011 $6,200,000 Robin J Kemper
Unit 12C - - - - - - Mar 1, 2010 $2,806,100 Adam Klein
Erica Klein
Unit 3A - - - - - - Aug 19, 2009 $3,500,000 Asa Abeliovich
Erika Klauer
Unit 5A - - - - - - Sep 10, 2008 $6,350,000 Richard S Davis
Mullarkey Maryanne
Unit 2C - - - - - - Sep 17, 2007 $2,900,000 Brad L Larson
Lisa L Larson
Unit 11B - - - - - - Jun 30, 2005 $3,413,700 Margot H Feely
Unit 3C - - - - - - Jun 30, 2005 $2,800,000 Kathryn K Conboy
Kenneth Conboy

Apartments for Sale at 1136 5th Avenue

UnitBrBaft²ListedListing AgentAskingPrice/ft² Common Charges Floorplans
Unit 1MD 2 2 0 Aug 17, 2021 Howard Margolis $1,650,000 - $5,535/mo -
Unit 1D 2 2 0 Jul 16, 2021 Corinne Pulitzer $1,650,000 - $5,535/mo

Apartments for Rent at 1136 5th Avenue

UnitBrBaft²ListedListing AgentAskingPrice/ft²Floorplans

Photo Galleries

Similar Buildings

More about 1136 5th Avenue

Located in Carnegie Hill, 1136 5th Avenue was first built in 1925 and is 96 years old. There are a total of 14 floors in 1136 5th Avenue, but good news, residents have access to 2 elevators. There are 21 closings on record since January 1, 1970, of which we have matching data for 7 listings. In the past 3 years, a listing in this building will typically remain on the market for about 168 days and tend to sell below the original asking price of $6,375,000 by -4.13%. Overall, the median closing price per square foot at 1136 5th Avenue is $2,461. In recent years, the longest days-on-market transaction was unit 9A, listed on November 18, 2014 for $5,950,000. This particular unit ultimately sold 306 days later for $5,950,000.The most recently closed transaction was unit 11B, which sold for $3,185,000 on July 28, 2021.

There are currently a total of 2 active listings. A breakdown of active listings shows 2 two-bedroom listings for sale. Unit 1MD is currently the lowest priced apartment in the building, with an asking price of $1,650,000. At the high end, unit 1MD has 2 bedrooms and an asking price of $1,650,000.

Last but not least, there are many great amenities and features for residents in the building. You can expect to be greeted by a doorman which means any packages you mail home will also be taken care of! Conveniently, the building has laundry machines. Best yet, washer and dryers are allowed in each unit. The closest transportation nearby is the 96th St 6 line.